Pros:
+ Nice open practice pin area right next to the parking lot.
+ Very friendly and welcoming regulars/locals.
+ Most tee pads are tesselated bricks/pavers. They are generously long and wide enough for big wind ups like mine.
+ 'Next hole' signs are prominent and visible!
+ Tons of space to wind up and explode on their truly open holes.
+ A peaceful community park serves as the grassy backdrop with a peppering of trees. I felt at ease here.
Cons:
- Tee signs are just laminated paper tacked to a post.
- Some tees felt way too close to walking paths. Holes 5 and 7 jump to mind as examples of this.
- Most of the holes are different variations of the wide open and flat glide. This causes many holes to feel samey.
- The white tees are all completely missing (as of February 17, 2019.)
- Some of the blue tee pads are just dirt for now.
- Most of the course is wide open and flat with just gentle slopes here and there serving as the elevation.
- Despite the open air, several holes feel ironically claustrophobic with the park's very many walking paths winding every which way around you. This will definitely cause problems in the warmer months.
- I did not see a lost disc box. (I could be wrong about this.)
Other Thoughts:
My favorite hole here was hole 3 because of the nice winding fairway it follows through some woods. It felt the most technical to me and, therefore, the most challenging. For a least favorite hole, I might have to go with the hole just before it. Hole 2 seemed the least interesting to my mind with its straight and wide open layout.
As for the course as a whole, Joe Palaia DGC is setting up to be a strong addition to New Jersey's disc golf scene. It will definitely earn a higher rating from me once it is completed, but it is not quite there yet.
I have to start this review by mentioning that right off the bat I was approached by two locals who enthusiastically offered to play the first few holes with me and tell me about the course in general. You know that you've chosen the right sport when complete strangers can walk up to one another and play as though they are friends. Joe Palaia disc golf has some good folks.
They did warn me about the course's downsides, though, which ought to get fair representation. They told me ahead of time that there are OB walking paths pretty much everywhere at this course, and they were right. Except for some spots in the back nine, the player is always either throwing towards or teeing off next to a footpath. I played in the middle of chilly February, and there were still dozens of people walking about. I can only imagine what kind of problems this might cause in the summertime. Throw with caution, but don't be afraid to wait for the right moment, folks.
Also, some of the fairways were permanently saturated. The locals I met said that hole 4 in particular had to be completely relocated because the woods through which it used to play were utterly mired.
The course is mostly flat, after all, which doesn't allow for much drainage. In the interest of fairness, it has been an unusually rainy winter for New Jersey, but flatness doesn't help the course in any case.
What does help the course, however, is variability between holes. The designers of this course seemed to understand that they had very little in the way of elevation to work with, so they kicked up the course-specific challenges in order to compensate. This was executed to great effect.
My favorite example of this is hole 14. The planners could have left it all alone and made it a wide open hole like many of the others. However, they chose to raise the basket at the end to add a bit of drama to the putting AND force the player to obey a bottleneck mando between two trees for an extra garnish of challenge to the driving. Working with what you have and polishing the experience is what makes a great disc golf course.
This course, as it is still quite new, does not have any of the short tees installed yet, but it does have 14 out of the 18 long tees planted and ready, so it is perfectly playable. And when I played, I had a very good time. Yes, the course it mostly flat and open, but the variability between holes and their features bumps it up a bit. The trees are not to be ignored here. They may seem off to the side, but don't let their apparent distance trick you into getting complacent. I look forward to playing here again in the future to see what kinds of additions are made and how the short tees play...!
Bottom line: The flat and mostly-open format is broken up by a fair few curve balls that make it more pleasant to play. No short tees (yet) mean that new players may feel a bit frustrated, and this course definitely favors the power players out there. However, Joe Palaia DGC has some fun holes to offer the disc golfer. It dares you to throw as far as you can and then smacks you with devious hybrid-style hole. It is on its way to being a core course of NJ.