Pros:
(3.313 Rating) (REVISED - replayed March 2023) A heavily wooded layout on top of a flat mountain.
- NATURAL BEAUTY - Monte Sano State Park is a splendid forested mountainous area with lots of hiking and biking trails in addition to the disc golf course. Located just 15 minutes from downtown Huntsville, this course is easily accessible for players doing a sweep of the Huntsville area courses. Although there are no drop-dead gorgeous views from the layout itself, a short 150-foot walk from basket (4) has views over McKay Hollow Valley and a waterfall. As for the course itself, fully wooded and there are some mini creeks that come into view and play. There are some mild elevation changes as well. During late fall, Monte Sano is arguably the most beautiful course in the area. Overall, I have Sano ranked 6th in Northern Alabama for beauty, after Kudzu, Flying Dragon, V-Rock, Sharon Johnston and Joe Wheeler. The course loses quite a bit of charm from December thru March.
- CHALLENGING - IMO, the second most difficult 18 hole course in town after Indian Creek which is something I personally cherish about the course. A bit more difficult than UAH, Mastin and the new Sharon Johnston course. Lots of 300 to 350-foot tunnel shots and some have considerable shot shaping requirements. The difficulty reads most closest to upper MA2 level with a mix of front and back placements and it will be much more challenging in the summer versus the winter. Figure MA2s will average around even par and MA1 level players will average 3 to 4 down. Players that excel in accuracy over distance or vice versa will skew these figures by a shot or two. When positioned in all longs, The course is a great MA1 level test.
- HOLE VARIETY - Above average. As noted above, lots of tunnel shots with basket placements finishing in both directions, although far more do finish to the left. Lots of tree gaps and fairway windows to hit. A few 15 to 25-foot elevation changes but it could have been way much more (see cons, Elevation). A few small creeks to play across and one hole has recently been relisted as a par 4 for the long placement on (14.) The hole distances vary a good bit, from 200 to 500 feet depending on basket placements.
- NAVIGATION AND SIGNAGE - Near perfect. There is a big new course map posted on the community board. Hole signage is also new with all the distances updated. In addition, there are well constructed and informative navigational markers everywhere along the layout. These markers to date, are still among the most effective I've ever seen on a heavily wooded course.
- REPAIRED TEES - The tees were in bad shape pre November 2018. Although they are still below average as they are new carpet pads, they are light years better than the 18 tripping hazards from before. Most are very flat and it will be a good couple years before they go downhill again. Three tees have been upgraded to pavers and hole (17) has a wood deck with turf surface.
- AMENITIES - In addition to improved tees, the course has gotten some additional niceties. Tee seating is present on about half of the holes. Also eight alternate basket placements, basket flags, park shelters and full tee shading. The course however doesn't have extra tees or a practice basket.
Cons:
Monte Sano has been getting attention since late 2018, but some things are hard to fix.
- LACK OF ELEVATION - Not a flat course, but for being located on top of a mountain and 1,000 feet above Huntsville, I am shocked by how flat the course is. Not one hole on the entire layout changes by 30 feet. Hole (9) changes the most, approaching the 30-foot mark, however the elevation prominence is lost on this hole as it's 500 feet long. Hole (12) has a nice 20 to 25-foot valley and there are a few other holes that have 15 feet of elevation play in them. All stated, it could have been a whole lot more.
- FORGIVENESS - Like most heavily wooded courses, Monte Sano may not be kind to some misguided shots. Over my 14 recorded rounds, I think my clean runs to within circle 2 is under 60 percent. Being a good mid range thrower to scramble for par will be key to shoot low.
- PAY TO PLAY - Currently its $5 to enter the park per person (less for seniors and children.) A yearly pass can also be obtained for those that live in the area at $100 or for families for $150.
- BEGINNER FRIENDLY - This is not a Beginner's course or even a Novice level course. Although the odds of losing a disc is lower than some courses, the course is way too tight to provide any enjoyment to inaccurate new throwers. Players also need about a 250-foot arm to have a realistic chance to chalk up a few birdies. The course would garner a lot more appeal if it had short tees on about half the holes.
- TIME PLAY - Not the quickest play. A round will likely involve some searching and lots of recovery shot planning. I spend well over an hour here for my solo rounds and well over 2 hours on group rounds.
Other Thoughts:
One of my favorite courses in the area as I personally like medium length wooded technical courses. This will definitely test a player's resolve and patience as bad kicks are almost certain. I personally would not bring a newer player up here, I'd take them to either Brahan or Southside instead. However, this course should work great for MA2s and MA1s looking to improve their precision. Overall, the course is really good despite a few blemishes. With all the recent improvements, I recently bumped Monte Sano above the 3.25 threshold for a 3.5. Seasonally however, it would drop back to the 3.0 level from December thru March due to the lost charm and increase in disc loss potential. Players that have already hit Indian Creek, Sharon Johnston and Brahan should consider this among the next courses to hit along with Redstone, Mastin Lake and UAH. Personally I rank Monte Sano 5th among the 20 DGCR listed courses within 25 minutes of downtown Huntsville. Regionally, it reminds me of courses such as, Mastin Lake, Joe Wheeler and Flying Dragon.