• Discover new ways to elevate your game with the updated DGCourseReview app!
    It's entirely free and enhanced with features shaped by user feedback to ensure your best experience on the course. (App Store or Google Play)

Recent content by ludds

  1. L

    can a player play from on top of a bush?

    So actually another question! Nothing here seems to say you CANT play on an obstacle. What am I missing? The lie is the place on the playing surface upon which the player takes a stance in order to throw. The playing surface is a surface, generally the ground, which is capable of supporting...
  2. L

    can a player play from on top of a bush?

    That helps! Thanks for the discussion everyone! I think it would be much less confusing if there were a more detailed definition section in the rules somewhere as some of the rules are pretty wide open to interpretation from how they are written which can make it hard to use a rule correctly.
  3. L

    can a player play from on top of a bush?

    Yeah it was a casual round so we weren't that worried about forcing him in. He did try but he couldn't get behind where the disc had landed in the bush without being on top of the bush. My question is more what specific rule/rules designate that he wouldn't be allowed to stand on the bush since...
  4. L

    can a player play from on top of a bush?

    This gives you an idea of what it looked like. I'm partly wondering where in the actual rules it states something like a bush isn't something you can stand on because I can't really find a rule that really has wordage about it.
  5. L

    can a player play from on top of a bush?

    There was definitely no physical way for him to even get a foot and his body behind even laying down. If the bush is sturdy enough, is he allowed to stand on it? It was still moving when he shot because even though it was sturdy, it still bent with his weight.
  6. L

    can a player play from on top of a bush?

    This happened in a casual round and I'm wondering how to play it out by the rules. Players disc landed on a large bush. The branches of the bush were thick enough that he couldn't take a stance behind it on the ground. He stood on the bush about 4 feet in the air to throw. Is that legal or...
  7. L

    how would you rule on this very strange scenario?

    So if his other foot was well outside the space behind the lie, not putting his foot fully in the water to touch the ground behind the disc would be an illegal stance.
  8. L

    how would you rule on this very strange scenario?

    Playing at a course that had some rain water and my friends disc went in the water. It was maybe 3-5 inches where his lie was. He then attempted to throw with one foot on land and one foot "touching the surface" of the water which was the spot of the lie. I am wondering if you have to put your...
Top