Pros:
This course deserves a fresh review. I think the cumulative average rating of 3.0 is low, and mostly based on specific conditions found in the past.
+ VARIETY: The course features a lot of variety, and it will test different skills. Take the first four holes: #1 is down into the woods, with lots of trees to kick a shot you don't control from elevation. #2 is up a nearby hillside, with the basket tucked behind a large rock at the crest. #3 is a long, flat wooded alley, and #4 is a wide open downhill. That basket is tucked just left, with a seasonal runoff stream right behind it
+ The course continues with multiple transitions between open and wooded holes. The elevation changes are less dramatic after the opening, but truly flat holes are rare
+ CHALLENGE: While this isn't a particularly long course, there's almost always some obstacles near the basket, so there's a premium on being able to find the right line 280'-300' away from the tee. There's only one par 4, so you might find yourself scrambling to make par more than you would expect on a 5300' course
+ This course isn't some championship style monster that's going to beat you up at every turn. There are a handful of short and easier holes sprinkled in. You're going to make pars, you will have some birdie opportunities. But it you don't stay alert, you're also gonna card a bunch of bogies
Cons:
- ONE BAD HOLE: #15 is a poorly designed sharp dogleg with most of the distance after the turn. It's a 90 degree right: less than 100' to the corner, and more than 200' after it.
Other Thoughts:
~ There are a couple of spots where it helps the first time player to walk ahead before throwing. #9 is across a field and into thick woods - the basket is farther to the left in the woods than you think it is, given the alignment of the tee. From the tee on #6, it isn't obvious where the sharp left dogleg is (play as close to the OB road as you dare, or you'll choke off your approach)
~ The course is very spread out - it's a long play for 5300'. There are a few transitional walks and it's a long walk back to the parking lot from #18. Pro Tip: Start on #8 (which is a forgiving open hole for your starter). You still have the long walk from #18 to #1, but you'll end your round near the parking lot
~ The layout plays through other activity areas. Most notably the open field on #8 has lots and lots of clay pigeon fragments under foot...because you're crossing the skeet shooting range (!)
COURSE AMENITIES:
Fading wooden signs and worn gravel tees; DisCatcher baskets in good shape. A few tricky places to navigate without a map or uDisc. I used my cart with no real trouble once past the wooded hills on the first two holes. Lots of parking, the Legion welcomes disc golfers to the bar.
RECOMMENDED COMBINATIONS:
I found the American Legion course to be much better than any of the closest courses, four of which I played on the same day. To the north, Nesbitt Park is just OK (a wide open 9); Linesville and Francis Walter Dam to the South are less enjoyable to play - compromised by terrain or poor upkeep. Knowing what I do now, I would have stayed and played American Legion a second time