Pros:
Glorious natural splendor reigns supreme at Black Falls DGC. There are plenty of different types of shots to be made. A few holes lean toward open and grassy, but may still have trees bordering the fairways, elevation changes, and water hazards. The bulk of the course play the lanes through woods, also with considerable elevation ups and downs.
There are two sets of tees, and two sets of baskets. Longs are gold, shorts are silver. I played the long tees/short baskets layout (gold/silver). Long layouts are par 58, shorter is 54. It's awesome that there is plenty of versatility. The tee boxes are very well laid pavers, pnice and level. Tee signs are posted at each tee. Baskets are all in nice condition.
Nine hole loops take you back to the parking area as you "make the turn".
The first tee is downhill, fairway is grassy and has air space to work with. There are woods as you reach the lower end of the hole, so you must be careful not to drift too far from center. The baskets are both set on the fringes of the woods. 2-8 are densely populated with trees and accuracy is crucial. There are some short holes, so well place drives will give you birdie chances. I loved this portion of the front nine. Late summer gave us a great day to enjoy the lush green forrest. The gold tee on hole 3 was mossy and moist, it felt like a scene from Princess Mononoke or Fern Gully. Didn't see and gnomes but maybe they hid under a mushroom or in an old hollow log. A great, longish hole that has a bend to the right on the approach to the baskets. 4 is a drive down the hill, with the silver pin near the bottom. If you go for the gold, the drive sets up a long second shot to the top of the next ridge. It's a doozy, but I didn't play the long pins. 5 tees from near the top of that ridge, and has trees guarding the pins at the bottom. Finding the gaps can be tricky. 9 comes back to the lawn, and drives up the hill again.
The view from the gold tee on hole 10 is pretty sweet. It is back downhill, lined by trees on both sides. The short pin is left side as the tree line breaks. Got my midrange disc very close, but I missed the birdie putt. Next few holes are back and forth through woods again, less elevation, varying shot shapes and distances. Hole 18 is a nice closer. There are split fairways, with ponds on the right fork, and trees in the center. I went for it on the right side and a branch knocked my disc into the water. Luckily it was on the edge and I was able to grab it easily. Had I seen the silver basket from the tee I would have went left side, but it was a really fun shot anyway.
Cons:
Not too much for me to gripe about here. It is pay to play, a fair ask considering the upkeep. Grass was mowed, fairways were clear, good signs all around and equipment was proper.
Some of the holes don't vary too much from the silver pin to the gold. I think one pin would be enough on several of them, but it must be nice to have the choice if you're lucky enough to play there frequently. It is not quite the championship caliber layout of Smug's but a really fun track and gorgeous scenery.
Other Thoughts:
Black Falls was worth the drive for me. It rained a lot the previous day, but the course was still very playable. Very little mud, puddles or evidence of the storm left at all. I was pleasantly surprised how well it had drained.
I shot a 58 on the gold/silver, 4 over par. Got deuces on holes 8, 9 and 17. Holes 2, 4 and 18 hit me with 5's as well as a bogey 4 on hole 16. I would have loved to get in 2 or 3 more rounds, be a little more familiar with the layout and see what kind of score I could post.
I would recommend a trip if you can make it. This is a very fun course that is reasonably challenging and fair. I see that the area has a few other courses that are newer. If I get half a chance I am flying back into Burlington and trying to cruise this area again. It is unlike anything we've got around KC.