Pros:
Beyind anything else, Lake Russell is a fun course to play. And fun is good, right? (That's what Dr. Seuss says)
The aesthetic of the course is quite good. With mowed fairway and slightly higher "rough" outside, the course has a golf course feel.
The course is set in rolling hills on abandoned (or acquired through eminent domain) pasture land near Lake Russell on the Georgia-South Carolina line. Things I love about the course.
The course has a good mix of straight shots and shots which require an anyhyzer/hyzer line (depending on your throwing style)
Good signs on each hole which give a rough map, distance, and par (see cons for further details on par)
Decent concrete tee pads
Good maintenance on the fairways, with a well mowed fairway with higher rough. The higher rough is not so high you can't find your disc, though.
There is a good mix of shorter ace runs and longer holes where a strategic first and second shots leads to a 3.
Risk and reward is present on many holes with the evergreen trees (Cedars and Junipers, I think) that swallow up discs if you stray off the fairway.
The course has one of the best flows of any of the 100+ courses I have played. It just seems like a natural progression from hole to hole. There are signs after 6 that lead to 7, rather than the visible pad for 9.
Hole 9's basket loops back near the parking lot, so if you want to just play 9 (or a multiple thereof), you can.
The course doesn't get much use, so there is little worry for backups. On the last 2 days I played, I did not see another disc golfer. I did see a energetic turkey and several deer, though.
Benches are scattered throughout the course.
I really like 16a - i. It is almost a different course, with dirt teepads in the woods and 9 relatively short holes. It's a good break from the rest course on a hot sunny afternoon. You have a good chance for a birdie, but also a good chance for a bogey with a bad kick off a tree. Due to the lack of vegetation on the understory, you have little chance of losing a disc unless you bury one under the leaves.
Cons:
Pars. Maybe the pars remain from when the course was first installed. They do seem rather generous. I'm not sure what others think, but if I was assigning pars, I would make 8, 15, and 16 par 4 with the rest par 3.
Some of the baskets, especially on the back nine and 16a-i, are older and in less than desired condition. I don't think it a affected my score much, but I am not a fan of the old sloped Innova baskets.
There are no restrooms. water sources, or trash baskets on the course. There is a trash basket and aluminum can recycle bin at the parking lot. Plan accordingly
Holes 9, 10, and 11 are basically straight shots in an open field. Some elevation comes into play, but these holes lack a little of the shot shaping required on the rest of the course.
Some might say the $5 vehicle entrance fee and $4/day disc golf fee is steep, but I have the annual park pass and family disc golf pass.
When I most recently played the course, the basket for 16i was missing.
Other Thoughts:
This course is one of my favorites, and I'm not exactly sure why. There are more challenging courses, longer courses, and courses with more elevation. This course has such a nice flow to it, with the scenic appeal, that I always list it among my favorites.
This may sound trite or stupid, but I love the walk from 12 to 13. After you hole out on 12, you walk downhill on a rock lined path through the trees, to the ace/birdie run that is 13.
It is off of the beaten track, which is both a plus and minus. My wife and I camped at the state park, and I was able to get in an early morning round each day before she woke up.
The course is off the beaten track, so stock up on snacks and drinks before hitting the course. There is a decent selection of newer Innova discs at the office. One of the rangers is a disc golfer. He pulled out the Innova flight chart when I checked in and some ball golfers were talking about disc golf.
Cell phone service is spotty at the park. I found the vicinity of the practice was the only place I had cell service (Verizon) in the park.
With updates to the old and rusting baskets, I could easily bump up my rating to 4.5.