Pros:
Malabar was a lot tougher than I expected. Tight fairways with thick shule in abundance. Hit the lines here or be punished. I'm guessing that there are local routes, and ways to exploit the course if you know it well, since many of the obstacles are low brush, but playing the fairways as they are leads to a varied bunch of interesting lines. The best of them is probably 17. That tee is on a raised mound(12 shares the mound, but points in the other direction.) and the thrower is confronted with a choice of two paths: mirror images of each other, one goes left and the other right, but they both feature a narrow fairway and a wicked curve.
It's a strange layout, with multiple points where tees need to be walked by. I can definitely see where earlier reviewers could be confused. Without signs, this course would be a nightmare to navigate. However, the navigation aids are fantastic. Not only are you pointed in the right direction from the basket but there are many signs along the way. At every where confusion is possible, a sign is there. With all the winding around the paths between holes make, it's a really fun course to follow. I wonder how it plays when it's crowded though. I can't tell if it would be enhanced by all the times you walk past tees or if there would too much interference. For some reason I want to say it's a course that plays better in a large group but it's definitely a fun one either way.
Cons:
Until you are familiar with the course and the landing zones, there will be some rough times. You will be digging through some pretty thick stuff for your discs. Unless you habitually scout, there will be places where you read the sign, see the fairway in front of you, throw a shot that curves nicely around the visible shule and to where you think you want to land for a run at a birdie, but upon walking to your disc, find that there is scrub where you thought there would be open field. Part of that is due to the tee signs, which are very vague but part of that is the nature of this type of course.
It's also one of those courses that has a limited range of abilities that it appeals to. Great players will be bored, since they will be able to go over the top of everything and there isn't much distance to make it challenging. Big sky hyzers will help you score well here, but they won't really be fun. Newer players will be frustrated quickly with the technical fairways and constantly putting discs into nasty stuff. Really, you can throw in to the scrub twenty feet in front of you and be left scratching your head, wondering how your disc disappeared. It's really only those in-between players that will and can play the lines as intended that will enjoy this course.
Other Thoughts:
I saw six tortoises. That's a course record for me.