Pros:
(3.267 Rating) (REVISED - replayed October 2023) A somewhat short technical course that's a blast to play.
- ELEVATION - One of only two courses in Huntsville with a bunch of 25 foot plus downhill shots. Holes (9), (12), (14) and (17) are all downward in the 25 to 35-foot grade change range. The only other course in the Huntsville area that does this is V-Rock. In addition, there are also a few fun up shots as well on (7), (10) and (11), which are all in the 20 to 30-foot range. Players that have bad knees or ankles should stay clear of this course. Bringing a disc golf cart out here is probably doable, but not ideal.
- ACE RUNS - Not the easiest course to ace in town due to the technical nature of the course, but many of these baskets are exhilarating to run at in my opinion. The layout is fairly short and several lines are less than 10 feet wide. I've had several close calls already here where I've admired my drive from the tee hoping for the sound of chains, only to watch it skip harmlessly by the basket or to get picked off late by a guardian tree.
- CHALLENGE - Judging Mastin Lake's difficulty solely on its length would be a mistake. Although an MA1 player could easily go 8 down or more here, they will also post up rounds over par on a day where every branch seems to move into the line after the throw. The course is going to produce some great scoring battles. A lead of 6 shots after 12 holes could easily vanish as holes (13), (14) and (17) are all five-able with a poor drive and bad ricochet. There's even a local term in the area call getting mastin'd, which is a round with a couple of horrible ricochets that ruin a round.
- SHOT SHAPING - Some of the lines at Mastin look borderline impossible to make a clean run at the basket, (4) alternate tee, (13) and (14). Basket guarding is excellent on many holes and those that have mastered shaping flights will obliterate players that can only throw bombs.
- SKILL LEVEL FRIENDLY - During the winter, Mastin Lake opens up quite a bit. I've brought a first timer during that time period and they loved it. The course is easily two throws easier to skilled players over the winter and perhaps five throws easier to unskilled players. However, bringing a beginning player here during the summer peak overgrowth is not a wise idea.
- NATURAL BEAUTY - Considering all the elevation changes and also the older trees, one of the better looking courses in Huntsville. A local named Adam O, has put in a ton of work here the last couple years and lines have never looked better IMO. A couple of the lines are worthy of pulling out the phone and snapping a photo. On the other hand, there are also some surrounding elements that have some less than desirable views. There are baseball and tennis court fences in view on 3 holes. These views all occur along the open west boundary of the layout.
- NAVIGATION - Not too bad... I think. I've probably played it too many times now to know if it's hard to follow. There is an updated map on DGCR, but none posted on site. There are a bunch of well-placed directional cues to keep players on track between holes. IMO, the only tricky transition is between (3) and (4) where there's a bit of a back track down (3s) fairway.
- QUICK PLAY - Players that are in good shape should have no problem playing this one in under an hour solo. Groups of four should be able to play in less than two hours, but there will likely be one player in the group needing to take a break at a few holes due to all the elevation changes.
Cons:
A solid technical course that really only has preferential issues.
- NO BOMB-IT HOLES - Players that only enjoy grip'n and rip'n probably won't like this course. Only one hole approaches 400 feet, hole (13), and it's probably the only time that an MA1 will bring out a full power driver as it's a bit uphill. There are a few other shots over 300 feet, (8), (9), (14) and (17) but they are all downhill and my weak arm can get to all of them.
- FORGIVENESS - Although short enough for MA3 level players, for those that can't hit 10 to 15 foot lanes consistently, this course can become very self-defeating. In addition, regardless of skill level, players will hit trees several times out here. When there's a ricochet in the wrong direction, scrambling for par may take a miracle. I had one of my best par saves ever out here on hole (17), where a bad kick on an early tree left me over 50 feet deep into the thicket. I pitched out and then threw in a 150-foot par save.
- LEAVES - Playing this course in the couple months after all the leaves have dropped can be a nightmare. It is literally inches thick in dead leaves. Before I knew better, I used to throw here in November and December and I'd often spend more than 10 minutes scouring leaf piles trying to find one disc.
- POISON IVY - I've spotted this awful plant at several spots along the layout.
Other Thoughts:
Mastin Lake has seen so much volunteer love in the last two years, that it has ticked up a half star on my ledger. Mastin was the first course I ever played in Alabama back in 2014. Personally, one of my favorites in the area as Mastin Lake is one of only two courses that offers respectable elevation changes in the Huntsville metro area. Players looking to make a disc golf tour of the Huntsville area should definitely consider this one if they plan to play 3 or more courses during their visit. Players that live within an hour need to play this course at least once. Having played 139 Alabama courses as of this revision, I think its worthy of a top 20 state billing, but not a top ten state course. Courses that it reminds me of include; Monte Sano in town, Greg Carter in Birmingham, Bowers in Tuscaloosa, East Roswell in Atlanta, Seven Oaks in Nashville and Meeman Shelby in Memphis.