Pros:
Update in 2019- I had not played here in 10 years (when this course was brand new) and I was very pleased with how mature the course now looks and plays. The fairways are still mostly tight, but very reasonable now. Navigational aids are abundant and match the style of all the hiking trail markers in the park. Many holes had 2 possible placements, and I appreciated that the markers on the tee sign were there and always correct.
From 2009- New 18 hole course to add to what is already a good disc golf city in Huntsville, AL. The course was very shady and provided some relief as we had to battle the Alabama summer heat. The custom baskets are neat, and give the course and each hole some personality. Very nice signs at every tee. Navigation was a breeze- there were already well-worn paths, but I really liked the orange spray paint dots on the trees to help you get from one hole to the next (as some holes have decent walks and you cross the road a few times.)
Cons:
Update in 2019- Fee is now $5/adult to enter the park. Tees are still carpet but were exceptionally flat, way different than last time. Concrete is preferred to me, but had no issues today. Reading my comments below, there must have been some redesign because 18 ended right back in the parking lot to where 1 begins. And I thought the difficulty and interest level and variety were the same from beginning to end, or at least from front 9 to back 9.
Fairways to me are no longer cons. Either they have been able to remove a few more trees over the years, or I am more tolerant, or I am better (maybe some of each), regardless my opinion from 2009 is no longer valid.
From 2009- The fee is $2/person, not per vehicle, to enter the park. Right now the tees are in the form of very lumpy carpet. There are some long walks between holes that look like they would have made a good hole, maybe better than an existing hole. Overall, the back nine to me are weaker than the front, which is always anti-climactic when the best holes are at the beginning. #18 ended in the middle of the woods with no signs pointing as to which path was the way out.
The biggest con, however, were the "fairways" which should be called "luckways" for many of the holes. As others have said, the park has limited the trees that could be cut down, but there needs to be a few more trees cut down. I am not saying make it easy, but holes with realistic paths that require pinpoint accuracy and skill are always better than "close your eyes and hope for good luck." I will admit there was more room to throw than I had expected based on the course description and other reviews, but there needs to be just a bit more refining on several of the holes.
Other Thoughts:
Update 2019- Course to myself on a nice spring Saturday late morning round. The drive up the mountain and the cost of admission likely keeps many away, but if I lived here I would play here often because I love technical woods courses.
I was visiting with family and was able to sneak in a solo round while my kids played on the nice playground, which is the same parking lot as the course. Lots of parking, restrooms are there, plenty of picnic tables. Hiking and mountain biking trails abound if you like those things also.
I rated it 3.0 in 2009, and in 2019 I think it is still that, but on the high side of it (3.25).
From 2009- The water hazards are nothing more than small creeks, so no danger of losing a disc in water. This is a new course and is in pretty good shape already. There are ace and birdie opportunities, but you need to make a good shot and have some good luck for many of the holes. It has the potential to be a really good course, but as it is right now it just a shade above average.