• Discover new ways to elevate your game with the updated DGCourseReview app!
    It's entirely free and enhanced with features shaped by user feedback to ensure your best experience on the course. (App Store or Google Play)

New Melle, MO

New Melle Lakes

4.135(based on 15 reviews)
Filter course reviews

Filter reviews

Filter reviews

New Melle Lakes reviews

Filter
2 10
Otahk
Experience: 7 played 6 reviews
3.50 star(s)

Good Course 2+ years drive by

Reviewed: Played on:Aug 6, 2020 Played the course:once

Pros:

Two tees and several possible basket placements. Over half the course is through the woods. Well marked and easy to follow. Great warm up area at the entrance.

Cons:

Grass in fairways is thick and finding first hole for someone who hasn't played there can be a challenge.
Was this review helpful? Yes No
19 0
JoeDirt
Experience: 20.6 years 80 played 15 reviews
3.50 star(s)

Unlimited Potential 2+ years drive by

Reviewed: Played on:Oct 8, 2018 Played the course:2-4 times

Pros:

There are 2 pads for each hole. I played this course from the blues and reds. The blues are challenging. The reds are not too easy and feel just right. The terrain has elevation and water. The fairways you can tell were a former golf course and are well maintained in the open areas. The elevated baskets were photogenic and placed on boulders. The signage is good and navigation was easy. The tee pads were Championship quality. The holes:

My favorite holes were Holes 1, 3, 5, 6, 12, 14, 15, 16, and 17.

Our group included a 1000 rated pro, another pro who is a long distance bomber who can throw over 600 feet, and 3 other disc golfers that average between 930 and 960 rated rounds.

Some highlites from our round that were memorable:

Hole 3 was almost aced from the blue pad by the bomber. Hole 3 from the blue pad required a mental game plan for those of us that laid up and there was good score separation. My favorite hole from a mental game standpoint. (Hole 3 is a small green that is protected by water unless you can throw a massive drive). Hole 5 was fun from both blue and red. From blue it is a cool shot coming out of a tunnel into an open fairway. From the red it is a downhill ace run. Hole 6 was a good use of elevation and rocks and was my favorite hole from a photogenic standpoint. Hole 12 was fun from both blue and red. I liked red a little better, not because it was easier but it is fun to be able to see the basket from the pad and watch the flight over the pond in a straight run at the basket. Hole 14 was fun from both the blue and red pads, the distance seemed just right so that it would be a par 4 from the blue and a par 3 from the red, I don't remember what the sign had it marked but it was a good use of the open fairway into a nice green. Hole 15 an absolute distance hole from the blue and still a good pump from the red. I saw the bomber in our group 2 this hole twice from the blue pad, this will be a great spectating hole for a big tourney to watch these guys smash. And finishes on an elevated boulder. Love it. I was happy to just get a 4 on it, it's challenging to have to cover that much distance and have such a tough putt. I really like the line on 16, it's a good golf hole, but it deserves some constructive criticism. Hole 17 is a fun downhill line with a difficult green. It's a challenge from both pads, I was the only one that was able to keep one on the green and pocket a birdie, it's nice to see holes where you don't just have to hit the line but you got to have the exact right distance as well.

Cons:

A lot of the greens were not greens in my opinion. Most of the greens on the wooded holes had too many trees. I don't mind large trees around a green but not a fan off what we call scrub brush within 40-50 feet of the basket. Would provide much more of a Championship feel to get rid of saplings and low hanging limbs in the greens. Most of the wooded holes from the blues it was hard to understand what the line the designer has in mind, it truly felt like poke and hope. In some cases it seemed the blue pad wasn't just further away but was also not on the intended fairway. Also it seemed like a lot of the wooded holes there would be a tight fairway but than the basket and the green would be located off the fairway. To me a tight fairway should lead to the basket. The fairways for the red pads seemed much better in the woods. Notable holes that stood out in a negative way are as follows:

Hole 2, the green felt nonexistent. There was a great fairway but the green was inside the woods, I played the hole by staying in the fairway and had no access to the green from drives that stayed in the fairway line. The best shots on the hole were over the top Hyzers and tomahawks that we watched plinko down from the top. Hole 13 seemed to not have a fairway from either the red or blue pads. Pretty much the entire group either threw random rollers or just threw shots at the tree tops hoping to bounce threw. There was a range of scores but it didn't feel like golf. Hole 16 I loved the line and the use of elevation but the fairway just has too many trees in it. Hole 18 the tee pads are built in a way that you have to run uphill. Hole 18 was not a very exciting hole to finish on but I don't know how you could fix it.

Overall I saw a lot of Discs fly down fairways and hit their lines and end up with the same score as other who threw bad shots and didn't hit the line. Either it was because the good shots didnt have a putt at the green or there was no reward for landing in the fairway and the second shot from the fairway was the same difficulty as the bad shot from off the fairway. It definitly seemed like the fairways were not fair inside the woods...

Other Thoughts:

This was my first time playing a course with these types of baskets and I am not here to review baskets. I will just say I am not a fan of them, it felt like the cross chains pushed many good putts out that normally would stay. I will say if you hit the sweet spot which is dead center, not an inch right or left or low, they caught well. The baskets are brand new and they all match, that matters the most. And the choice of basket does not affect my review. After playing both sets of pads I would recommend a hybrid layout for a tournament. I would probably do the following: 1-Blue, 2-Red, 3-Blue, 4-Red, 5-Blue, 6-Blue, 7-Red, 8-Red, 9-Red, 10-Red, 11-Red, 12-Red, 13-eliminate(add a temp hole somewhere), 14-Blue, 15-Blue, 16-Red, 17-Blue, 18-Blue

I understand this a brand new course and a work in progress. I'm trying to give constructive criticism and I don't want all the negative to take away from how much fun we had playing the course from both pads. I think the blue pads will be excellent once there is more maintenance done. I can't wait to come back and play here again and I will absolutely make changes to this review as the course is further developed.
Was this review helpful? Yes No
11 4
mrbro855
Gold level trusted reviewer
Experience: 10.6 years 367 played 105 reviews
3.50 star(s)

Not your leisurely course... 2+ years

Reviewed: Played on:Oct 5, 2018 Played the course:once

Pros:

Beautiful course set in western St Charles county, out in the very rural part of the county.
The course boasts the usual amenities: great dual concrete tee pads, excellent signage, benches, next tee signs.

Prodigy Cross Chain Baskets- first time I have played them, thought they caught just fine- hit one long throw with no issue.


Beautiful area containing 3 water holes (of which I found one!) Elevation changes, while not alot came in to play on a few holes.


Multiple basket placements- so if you become a regular can give different looks.


Couple of memorable holes:

#3 Water hole - short basket at 197, needed about 165 to clear water- certainly manageable even for this 55+ y/o with mediocre tee shot.

#12 Another water hole with more risk reward opportunity. Basket was in short placement needing about 275 to clear water, but staying left allows a safe landing area.

#18 Tough dog leg left up a steep hill. Had to work to finish this course!!


Two baskets were mounted on high stone placements (#1 and 15) similar to hole 7C at College Meadows course.

Course seemed to blend the best elements of several other St Charles county courses such as College Meadows and Fort Zumwalt.

Cons:

For what the designers were striving for, there really are no cons.

A thought or two best put here, though... as course is new, there were still some noticeable piles of brush that will obviously be moved soon.


Lots of walking!! As it was built on an old ball golf course, there was a lot of real estate to use.

Other Thoughts:

This is definitely geared to be more of a championship caliber course. I was challenged playing red and looking at the blue tees was daunting!!

Full disclosure: I am a 55+ y/o relatively new to the sport (5 yrs). That said, this was course #237 on the climb to that next goal of 500. My favorite type of course is the "city park" type where I generally have decent opportunity to throw a birdie or two. Out here, I had none, though my 19 y/o son threw 3 birdies.

This is not a leisurely type course to play. I am curious due to the very remote location of this course, whether there will be sustained activity. I certainly hope so as it is a beautiful course and area.

As for rating, the course itself gets a 4 for its layout and amenities, while for me, the "fun" factor was a 3; netting a 3.5 very good course.





Was this review helpful? Yes No
Top