Pros:
Rolling Pines is an absolutely wonderful course. Great terrain, challenging holes and creative layouts all come together to form one of the best new courses of 2015.
- This course is a perfect mix of challenge and enjoyment. Playing the long tees was an absolute grind and yet I still somehow managed to have a blast throughout my round. The course and the designers took advantage of the course's biggest strength - the terrain. There's tons of elevation - hence ROLLING Pines - leading to great downhill and uphill layouts.
- The course starts out innocently enough with three relatively simple holes. These three holes are the easiest stretch of the course, so you better take advantage of it. Then you get to the meat of the course with hole #4, one of my two or three favorite holes. It's a 470 foot layout with OB running the entire left side of the fairway to an uphill shot to the basket. The further right you place your tee shot, you also have more trees between yourself and the basket.
- I thought #6 is a great hole as well. It's a tight, 265 foot downhill shot (165 from the shorts) to a hanging basket from a big tree. I threw from both the long and shorts on this hole, and I actually thought the short tee was tougher because of the gauntlet layout of trees on both sides of the fairway. I could see potential ace-runs on this hole just as easily as a bogey.
- The elevation also plays a big factor on a couple other fun/noteworthy layouts. On #9, the hill slopes down from right to left, so be prepared for a long uphill second shot if you're a RHBH thrower. The good news is your shot might end up close to the bath-house. Holes #11 & 14 can both be frustrating uphill shots because the baskets are heavily protected by trees. Of these two, I liked #11 better. Then you get to the enjoyment that is #15. It's the longest hole on the course at 665 feet, and being a downhill shot, you can finally unleash a big throw.
- The scenery here, for the most part, is terrific. This is disc golf only land, so it's basically you out in nature. The less-than-stellar part of the scenery is the water treatment plant that's visible from #9's basket/#10's tee area and #16. It's a water treatment plant and has brown water fountains. You do the math there.
- The course will also challenge the mental and physical aspects of your game. Walking up and down hills the entire time will start wearing a player down. The key is whether you can be playing as well in the closing stretch of your round as you did at the beginning.
Cons:
There's really not a whole lot to say bad about this place. The course had been officially open for less than two weeks when I played here, and everything seemed to be in great shape. That said, here are the couple negatives I noticed.
- As majestic as most of the course is, I'm not a fan of the holes that detract from the course's natural feel. I'm mainly talking about hole #16, which plays around the bath house. You go from nature to teeing off next to the treatment plant, throw over the park service road and around the bathhouse. That's a pretty stark contrast.
- The park is also used as a campground for MerleFest. While it's a great place to camp (can you say tourney and camping combo?), there were spots throughout the course where the grass had been burned away because they were fire circles for campers. My concern is whether, over the years, the grass won't grow back and each year more burn circles are formed in the grass. If so, what's picturesque now could lose a big part of that luster in 5 - 10 years.
- Parking lot is rather small. That could pose issues during a tourney/big event weekends.
- There's a lack of benches and trashcans throughout the course. I caught this course at its absolute peak, so no trash concerns...yet. Without many trash cans, we have to rely on 'pack it in, pack it out' disc golfers. As for the benches, well, they'll come in handy. The more of each, the better it will be for everyone.
Other Thoughts:
Rolling Pines blew me away with how great it was. For how much Highland Hills has failed to become a great course (underachieved); Rolling Pines exceeded my expectations (overachieved). There's a huge gap between the qualities of these two courses mostly due to the excellence that is Rolling Pines.
- The long tees are championship-level quality. I was able to hold my own on them for a while. By the back 9, I got to taste how relentless this course is. Each hole was one challenge after another; yet, I still loved it.
- The course does a great job of not feeling too repetitive. Throughout the 18 holes, it's easy to compare holes to others. Throughout the round however, you don't feel like you're ever playing the same hole back-to-back.
- I'll point out the most nerve-racking, if not challenging, hole on the course. #13 is a nasty, 345-foot, tight downhill hole. There's very little fairway to work with, so you better be accurate. The positive is that if you throw straight, your shot is going to sail a long way toward the basket. The problem is that if you miss the fairway, you might end up deep in the woods, as I did. And just like me, it might take a couple shots just to get back to the fairway, leading to a dreaded double-bogey.
- There are several spots on the course where there's risk for lost discs, or at the potential for long searches. To the right of the fairway on #1 is heavy woods down the side of a hill. The same goes for #12. Also, #13 offers the risk of a disc easily sailing deep into the woods. On these three holes, half the battle might just be find a safe way to get to your disc if it goes down one of the slopes. Keep in mind when debating what to throw and how aggressive to play.
- This is a no-brainer must play for anyone in the region. Between this course and Ashe County Park in Jefferson, that's one awesome day trip for people living in Charlotte, the Triangle, the Triad, etc.
- I'm giving this course a 4.5 rating. If I had the option, I'd probably 'only' give it a 4.25 rating. That said, it's more than qualified to merit the 4.5 'phenomenal' label.