Pros:
+ Course maintenance is excellent: on the Memorial Day weekend that I played, it was well-mowed and spotless. Each hole has three poured concrete tees, and the baskets are in good shape. The layout is largely open, with some baskets tucked into treed areas. But the course still plays as "technical" - on a windy day, the holes near the shoreline require very specific lines to avoid rough and OB
+ Nicknamed "The Beast" it's a long bomber course (9110' / 8120' / 6689') that shows you right away what it's gonna do. Hole #1 starts with a bang: 600+ par 4 from the white tees with an uphill finish, with the pin up beyond a bowl with staked OB. Then, a 700+' par 5, and another 600+ par 4, and so on. In fact, the shortest hole of the first third of the course is the 400' par 3 hole #4
+ Being right on the coast of Lake Ontario, long stretches of the course are pretty flat. A handful of holes (#8, #12 and #13) were cleverly designed to take advantage of the little bit of available elevation change, and they're a welcome addition
+ The green on hole #15 is circled by a ring of boulders, and at 217' from the Blue and the White (153' from the Red) can be played as an island hole (see card, not sign)
+ The basket on #18 is up on a man made mound, adding extra challenge and a finishing note to the course
Cons:
- Strangely, the really good course signage doesn't include specifics about OB, which is described in detail on the paper scorecard. But if you don't have a scorecard, you won't know that discs that go over the cliff on the shoreline are played inbounds unless they land in the water, and you won't know to play #15 as an island green. The tee signs include really good maps and show each of the three tee locations with lengths. If you're using uDisc and don't take a paper scorecard, you won't know about about some of the OB
Other Thoughts:
~ There are a couple of weak holes that I initially was going to include as "cons." But on reflection, I think the weakness of their design is only a problem if you haven't played them before, or walked them before your initial throw. So I'll describe them here in case you're thinking of playing the course for the first time:
- Hole #7 plays as a dogleg left, then finishes with a 90 degree turn to the right (think of an upside-down question mark [?] with the basket being the period). The sides are thickly wooded - they've probably grown a lot since the course opened. The best-placed shot leaves you with a 50+ footer through an alley with branches creating a ceiling. It's not a terrible hole, but it's a 200 footer that will most often be played as a dink-and-dunk for par
- Hole #9 needs to be walked to be understood (and appreciated). From the tees you're looking downhill through a thickly treed fairway to a clearing. A bad kick or an early fade could mean a rollaway to water that's hidden along the left side (that's one of the reasons to walk it first!). The basket is not visible from the tee: it's perched up on a hillside to the right, past the clearing with water curling in close at the base of the steep hill. This is a par 3 that's only about 300', but the "S" shape of the path to the basket probably means the hole is best played as a careful downhill layup into the clearing
RECOMMENDED COMBINATIONS:
There's a big difference between the two courses on this property. Playing WIndrush Alley didn't prepare me for how much more difficult The Beast is. I struggled due to the distance, since my best drives are under 300'. The course overwhelmed me, but it was never unfair. The Whites on The Beast are more like the Blues I find at other courses - and the Blues at The Beast are more like Golds elsewhere. Given my length, I would have done a lot better to have shifted to the Reds when moving from WIndrush to The Beast
Even though The Beast gets your attention, don't dunk on Windrush Alley. While Windrush is considerably shorter and scores easier, it features a lot more wooded, technical holes. The challenges of the two courses are different and complement one another. Play both courses - and then play them again!