Pros:
Jekyll/Hyde course. Holes 1-7 (except the no. 4 fairway) are tight and mostly short. Hole 8 along the edge of the parking lot is a good transition. Holes 9-18 are spaced further apart, over rolling terrain, mostly in dense woods. Varied.
The back 9 is hard on a beginner, but has some reasonable holes, including 9, 11, 13, 15-17.
Hole 7 opens to a wide, shaded green at the end of the fairway. Hole 12 requires a drive into a ravine and then back up to a ledge. Or from ledge to ledge if you are a strong thrower. Hole 15 is very pretty with its wooded fairway and open, sandy green. Holes 16-18 are in a sparsely-wooded meadow. Nice reprieve from the woods you've been in since the beginning. No. 18 is super long from the yellow and green tees, over open field, needs a turnover shot to get over the final fence. I found its tees for yellow and green (latter in a tight alcove of trees near the lake shoreline), but I never encountered the 300-foot red tee.
Many ponds and the main lake make for lovely scenery. I took alot of photos in 2019 and 2021.
New signs make a world of difference. Though placed mostly only at the yellow/long tees and not repeated at white or red (too much money, I imagine), the information on the signs is priceless for finding all 3 tees per hole. (NB: a large number of the white/red tees are combined.)
The basket of no. 10 has been placed at the end of a tunnel, and the white/red pad is out of the boggy mess but still on the safe side of the pond. This rearrangement now makes no. 10 playable for the short thrower.
Hole A (parallel to and between holes 5 and 6) is now well marked, so if you want to play 18 traditional holes and skip it, it's clear you are not missing a hole you want to play.
Perhaps it has been there all along, but there is a practice basket near the park road and on your way from no. 7 to no. 8. It's clearly marked too now, so no confusion if it is a second basket for no. 7.
Cons:
Jekyll/Hyde course. Rear 9 is distinctly tougher than the front 9. In addition to alot of walking and climbing, there is serious water to get over at 10 and 14 (also no. 9 for the yellow tee people). I can't yet handle big water, so I just don't play these holes. I write down par+4 and move on. There is now a drop zone for 14 that you can start from, shooting 3.
Course map online is incorrect, out-of-date. Use UDisc instead if you have it.
Some of the white/red tees are literally white rugs/mats and get covered by the white sand. Rather tough to find. No hole signs there. I had this problem at nos. 9 and 15.
I never found white/red tees for nos. 13 and 18.
Tee pads vary widely: some concrete, some mats, some natural, one paver at yellow 18.
Next-tee sign to no. 11's white/red tee is incorrect.
Two benches at 7 and 11; I believe the current one at 11 is a replacement and newer (thanks, local club/parks dept.). Some logs to sit on at a few other holes. However, mostly there is nowhere to sit and rest. Some of us need such.
Other Thoughts:
I first played this course Feb. 2019 when I was in the area. I was in the area more recently Aug. 2021 and have updated my previous comments here to reflect the new reality.
Go to hole 1 not via the trail into the woods but along the lake shoreline. The yellow tee is nearest the fishing pier. Keep walking and find the white tee inside a fence. There is also a red tee further up the hill. The basket for no. 1 used to be into the woods a bit. It is now at the end of a narrow fairway along the shoreline.
New signs make a real difference in your navigation and (thus) your degree of enjoyment. If you are not wasting time, trying to find holes, you can (um) play the holes!! (smile).
Vineland is a smaller town in the grand scheme of things: 61000 people or so. This is a quality course for a small place like this. With Route 55 connecting Vineland and suburban Philadelphia via a real interstate roadway, I imagine plenty Philly dolfers frequent this course.
Also makes a good day trip (perhaps add Cape May Zoo and/or Stafford Woods or New Brooklyn courses) for Delaware disc golfers wanting something different.
BTW the park is actually at 429 W Elmer Road and has been renamed after former city mayor Anthony Campanella Sr. So look for his name versus South Vineland Park,