Pros:
Sycamore Creek Church offers a unique opportunity, playing through different types of land behind a church. It offers more than you might expect from a church course, with an active club/tournament scene, practice basket, concrete tees, and nice new tee signs. There is also plenty of parking and while it may get crowded during church events, it looks like there is a corner tucked away for disc golfers.
I started out not being too impressed through the first few holes, but I ended up feeling that the course does have good variety in its totality. There are the moderately wooded, technical holes 1-5, 9-10, and 16-18, the open holes 6-8 and 11-13, and the tightly wooded holes 14-15. I particularly enjoyed the transition into the woods for holes 14-15, which came as a pleasant surprise compared to the rest of the course's setting. These were easily the most technical on the course and added some precision shots to make the course feel more complete.
Holes 5 and 17 were also fun, unique holes. 5 is an anny with a blind shot over a shallow stream with a basket on a tightly-cornered green. 17 is a pretty extreme anny with a basket on a peninsula. These holes were unique, especially with the rest of the course. Water comes into play on 2 other holes, adding to the course's challenge.
The baskets were in good shape and the fairways were well taken care of. Grass was cut short when I played.
Navigation is great for the most part and the course conveniently circles back to the parking lot.
Cons:
This course is definitely well designed with the property given, but there are some detractors to the land here. While there are some minor elevation changes, the course is pretty much dead flat.
Also, much of the course is on the open side, with a few too many completely open holes in the middle stretch. There really are only a few truly technical holes here, with many that do little to punish errant throws.
Only three holes are over 300 feet, with six holes under 200 feet. This course is short!
I can imagine a lot of problems when the rough is in full bloom. When I played in Oct, the rough was still pretty bad on some holes. It was disc swallowing on holes 3 and 4 and I think would be a big issue on the open holes in the spring/summer.
Hole 3 was hard to find and not an obvious path from 2, but it was the only confusing part of navigating the course.
Other Thoughts:
It was cool to play a church course that is well cared for and has an active club scene. I always appreciate when a church allows a course on their property, since it is a great way to introduce new players to the sport. I was however disappointed in all the trash that people left lying around the course. Beer cans everywhere is never an attractive thing, let alone on church property where they may be more likely to pull a course. Either way, Sycamore Creek is well worth checking out for a casual round.