Pros:
Wonderful setting for discing: clean, quiet, well maintained park, with nice eye appeal and nary a speck of trash. Plays through a lush valley featuring a massive hill.
• Solid course, appropriate for players of all skill levels players. Fairly long and open for the most part, allowing for multiple routes to the basket. Doesn't heavily favor lefties or righties, FH or BH, and while big arms will certainly like this place, their advantage is not overwhelming.
• Makes good use of natural elements to challenge and appreciate: well positioned trees/overhanging branches to force shot shaping. A river runs behind or along to the first several holes adding a scenic element. Certainly a factor on the 1st hole, it only should only come into play if you stray pretty far from the fairway. However, a sharp drop off between fairway and river can penalize you even if the disc stays dry. Large expanses of tall, scrubby grass, weeds, Queen Ann's Lace and such adorn or line fairways, encouraging you to take certain routes or hit clear landing areas.
• Decent baskets and mostly concrete pads.
• Intuitive layout flows well from basket to next tee. Good tee markers clear up the few questionable spots.
• A humbling 8th hole has you paying for 9 in advance: 200 ft straight up that massive hill to a guarded basket tucked in about 15-20 feet or so to the left of the fairway. Plenty of trees to make sure you hold a line or pay the consequences. A nasty roll away here could be one you never forget.
• Signature hole 9 is a beauty that I can only describe as a "tunnel-bomb." Tees off atop aforementioned massive hill, with thick brush on both sides of the fairway all the way down to the valley floor. The lane seems fairly wide, but you really need to huck it a long way down the hill to hit a clean landing spot to set up for pars or birdies. Discs that are grip-locked, fade prematurely, or get squirrely will yield a god-forsaken 2nd shot, if you're even able to find them. Conversely, the right combo of driver and shot execution are rewarded accordingly.
• Bonus 19th: Great hole (not just "OK for a throw-in"). Practice basket lines up directly in front of a somewhat elevated (concrete) pad, nicely framed by a couple of trees. A branch crossing from right to left invites you to launch one through this oversized doorframe, but you need to keep it fairly low to avoid the cross-bar branch and foliage above it. "Safer" hyzer and annie routes around this obstacle take a longer route to the pin.
Cons:
There simply aren't many things "wrong" here (certainly nothing glaring, and a couple can be fixed).
• Beautiful when I played, but I wouldn't dream of playing here after a good rain without waders - probably takes days to dry out.
• Looks like they moved a few tees around - has you teeing from a dirt patch in a few spots (but not all that bad).
• Holes converge in a few places. Shots from other players could be factor (but only if they're rude, as it's pretty easy to see people playing in the open).
• I'd suggest a spotter for 9.
• Could use a few tight holes: 8 and 10 are really the only holes where you're somewhat likely to hit multiple trees on a single hole.
Other Thoughts:
Simply a great course offering fun disc play. Pretty much nails basics and falls short in very few aspects. Although not explicitly stated, V.A. Barrie appears to be dedicated to disc golf for the most part: no other activities or facilities are present. About the only things here are baskets, tees, and a picnic table or two.
Despite (or perhaps because of) being in a bit of a bowl mostly surrounded by trees, wind was a factor on many holes. Moreover, it wasn't coming predominantly from one direction, but seemed to change as we progressed through the course. Somehow, I frequently found myself going to a more stable disc because of a headwind, but never needed to go less stable for a tail wind... hmmmmm.
In stark contrast to V.A. Barrie, nearby Waterworks offers quite the tight and technical mid/putter fest. As others have stated, these two courses complement each other very well for a great day's discing - worth a day trip to play them both. That being said, while Waterworks is a decent course unto itself, I just think V.A. is a much better course, and honestly don't understand how someone could rate them with a ½ a disc of each other. Then again, this site's all about player's opinions; they're entitled to theirs, I'm entitled to mine.