Pros:
I happened to be in the area for work and found that you could play the day to day version of the historic USDGC course so I had to wander over.
The campus is quite beautiful, it reminds me a bit of a compact version of Berry College in GA but Berry could only wish for their courses to be this good.
There is a fair bit of variety here, some pretty good elevation changes and of course the lake to deal with. Only a few holes I would say are wooded and they are more of a "park style" woods than anything typical of a southern wooded course. The majority of the holes just feel very solid, and well thought out, usually offering multiple lines especially if you can "break" a hole with a pro distance power hyzer or roller.
Upkeep is pretty solid, but I feel like it's not as polished as you would see if for USDGC or the AM doubles championship later this year.
Pads are a mix of turf and concrete and I didn't have any issues with them, they were mainly very large and worked great for what you needed on the hole.
The water carries on several holes including a 390ft version of the long par 4 from the gold layout were a very fun challenge. On that hole I threw my drive about 80 long trying to make sure it cleared the water. Course mainly plays shorter though, that was the only time I broke out a full power drive and it turned out to be overkill.
The gate hole is pretty iconic and to be able to say I hit the gap on my first try is pretty cool, though I did do it with a fairway and not the nose up putter shot you see many top pros park it with. A 2 is a 2 lol.
There are also some old school funky holes that you don't see on many newer courses, like 17 that has tree branches almost completely covering the pad, forcing you to throw a forehand or turnover out over the lake. I love a course that isn't afraid to challenge the player.
Cons:
The main cons stem from the fact that this is a legacy course with tons of old layouts and without a map of the current one navigating it would make you want to jump in the lake.
There are tee signs and even a few next tee signs, that are beautiful stone slabs on the ground. But locals informed me that was for a legacy layout and cannot be trusted at all.
There are a couple of holes that cross close to busy walking paths and once or twice it's blind, so you just really have to be careful since the property is so busy in general.
People fishing don't seem to be as afraid as they should be of a disc going over their head. I was waved on a few times and it was uncomfortable.
Upkeep was good with the exception that all around the lake the are massive amounts of goose poop. I'm not really knocking it for that, but it's everywhere on those holes and you need to be ready for it.
Other Thoughts:
It's a fun time and throwing some of the shots you have seen in video is pretty cool. I think everyone who is close enough to play should try it.
Maybe a 4 is a touch generous, but it's better than a 3.5 in all but amenities. Maybe I'm just a bit sappy about a course I've wanted to play for a decade as well. In any case it was one of the more fun new courses I've played in some time and I think most players would have a blast here.