Valley Springs, CA

New Hogan Dam - West

Permanent course
3.725(based on 9 reviews)
Filter course reviews

Filter reviews

Filter reviews

New Hogan Dam - West reviews

Filter
3 1
The Valkyrie Kid
Diamond level trusted reviewer
Experience: 45.9 years 1562 played 1507 reviews
2.50 star(s)

New Hogan Dam West DGC Is Not Friendly To Traveling Players! 2+ years

Reviewed: Played on:Jan 21, 2019 Played the course:once

Pros:

This course was terribly frustrating to me, a very experienced traveling player. To start with, there is a little mail box type thing with Disc Golf Brochures. They were totally useless! They listed how disc golf is played. They had a scorecard for keeping score. They didn't have a map! And they didn't tell you which is the East course and which is the West course.

There is a kiosk at the start. It has no pertinent disc golf information. There is a large natural tee area here with a # 1 sign pointing two ways. One is obviously for the West course and the other # 1 is obviously for the East course but they are IDENTICAL except for the distance.

Common sense hints for Ranger Rick.

1. When you have two courses side by side, how about letting the public know which course is which? Maybe something in the sign like the word East or West! Or maybe different color maps for each?

2. When you make a course map and you have two complete 18 hole courses, don't squeeze it onto one piece of 8.5" X 11" paper in 4 point font. Try enlarging it so each 18 hole course fills one page. This also apples to Lake Amador who's map is about the same font.

The course has the old school fiberglass signs. I'm thrilled that they have held up so well. No vandalism out here. The baskets are silver DGA models with no #'s. They are so difficult to spot in the surroundings here. The tee pads are sometimes dug out natural, sometimes just on the path and in some places nothing

Cons:

No course map.

On-line map was impossible for me to decipher.

Poor signage and navigational aids.

Long open holes without almost no shot shaping needed.

Other Thoughts:

My vote for signature hole goes to the three rocks? What? On hole # 5, someone has fashioned this wonderful chair out of three of the rocks that are everywhere. Speaking of chairs/benches, the West course has zero and the East course has one. I needed one at every hole.
Was this review helpful? Yes No
2 1
Chad McBallerson
Experience: 20.9 years 122 played 9 reviews
3.50 star(s)

Nor Cal Disc Golf Course Preview Review 2+ years drive by

Reviewed: Updated: Played on:Oct 16, 2016 Played the course:2-4 times

Pros:

- Parking lot
- Bathrooms
-Signage
- Good layout
- elevation change and water hazards
- tee boxes

Cons:

- summer is very hot and dry with long grass
- rattlesnakes
- have to pay to play
- tee boxes and tee signs need some love

Other Thoughts:

New Hogan has 2 solid 18 holers. The west plays next to the lake while the East stays more on the hill. They have a pretty fun lay outs with a variety of middle to long range shots. It seems like when it was first put in, it probably was pretty nice, but could you a little love and update. It has elevation change, water hazards but pay attention to the time of year because it can be extremely hot, have tall grass, and rattle snake sightings.
Was this review helpful? Yes No
3 1
kevaunne
Experience: 15.9 years 40 played 19 reviews
4.00 star(s)

Beautiful, fun & challenging 2+ years drive by

Reviewed: Played on:Apr 26, 2014 Played the course:once

Pros:

- Strong design. Great shot variety required. For the most part, holes felt distinctive and flowed well. Lots of different hole distances.
- Fun big downhill throws where you can watch your disc flyyyyy. 17 is epic
- Decent signage. Maps on 1st teepads are very helpful.
- Hilly, rocky, lightly forested, & grassy. This is prime disc golf terrain.
- Great wildlife viewing. We saw a group of deer and a large vulture during our round
- I thought I'd be griping about the dirt teepads but they were flat and packed down. No problems at all, even after a rainy day.

Cons:

- The baskets aren't the best. They're shallow and the chains seemed thinner which led to some frustrating putts. Flags or markers would have been extremely helpful. Also an indication of basket position would have been nice. We had to do a lot of scouting before teeing off.
- Burrs EVERYWHERE. My dogs and shoes got blanketed.
- Rattlesnake country.
- Sometimes obstructions (bushes, trees) were too close to the basket. There were approaches where I intentionally threw into a bush or tree knowing that it would catch my disc for an easy drop in.

Other Thoughts:

This course is quite pleasant and challenging! I had a wonderful day here soaking in the scenery and throwing discs.

Use some caution and planning before playing here. Bring lots of water, avoid this course on a hot day and be prepared for burrs. Water and bathrooms are a bit of a walk away from the course. The water out of the drinking fountain was the some of the tastiest and pure I've ever had. I think it came directly from the reservoir yummm
Was this review helpful? Yes No
2 1
bykergus
Experience: 11 years 13 played 11 reviews
4.00 star(s)

Fun and Scenic 2+ years drive by

Reviewed: Played on:Dec 31, 2013 Played the course:2-4 times

Pros:

Lots of different shots. Baskets in great shape. Water hazards along the lake starting with hole 11. The bank - when the lake is UP - is steep into the water and rocky under the water. You'll get your disc back when the water goes down.

Cons:

Not that I could find.

Other Thoughts:

Hole 11 is fun. Over the water is a long shot, or, go around. It's a nice sized cove.
Hole 17 - almost 800 feet in the long position. But watch out. I went past it on my second shot and nearly ended up in the water about 150' past it. That hole is a kick to shoot at. I'm such a beginner - I had no idea I could throw a disc that far, even down hill.
Was this review helpful? Yes No
5 0
mashnut
Diamond level trusted reviewer
Experience: 22.2 years 831 played 777 reviews
3.50 star(s)

Nice views 2+ years drive by

Reviewed: Played on:Jul 2, 2013 Played the course:once

Pros:

The course plays on the slope from the top of the ridge down toward the lake. Many of the shots have elevation in play, with a couple fun downhill holes, some tricky uphill shots and some fun rollaway opportunities in landing zones and around pins. There is nice variety in distance, with several reachable shots and plenty of longer bombs where you get to open up and throw a real drive.

There are a few shots where there are enough trees to force some slightly tighter lines, otherwise the main obstacle is wind and distance. There are lots of great spots to enjoy the view out over the lake. Like the other course, some of the larger trees and rock piles are used well to make fun pin placements. When the water is up in the lake a few holes have the potential for cool risk/reward shots. The tees are natural, but are hard packed and level so I had no problems throwing from them.

Cons:

Unfortunately the water was low when I played so I didn't get to play any of the shots with water in play (not a con that affected my rating, just a disappointment). The course is very open overall, and doesn't test any real line shaping or technical skills. You can score well with nothing but a controlled hyzer.

The signage is inconsistent and not very accurate, especially in the area where the two courses play close to one another. A few spots could use some next tee signs as well. The grass can get a little long and full of fox tails, gaiters or pants might be a good idea.

Other Thoughts:

Beginners will find the course pretty long, but won't have too much of an issue recovering from errant shots. Experienced players will enjoy the chance to throw some long drives and the elevation and wind make for some challenges but the lack of technical challenges makes the course a bit repetitive. This is the better of the two courses, both are worth a stop if you're in the area.
Was this review helpful? Yes No
2 5
elton807
Bronze level trusted reviewer
Experience: 13.8 years 56 played 56 reviews
5.00 star(s)

Hogan's Hero 2+ years drive by

Reviewed: Played on:Jul 11, 2013 Played the course:once

Pros:

Easily one of my most favorite courses I've played (along with La Mirada, Stafford and Golden Gate). Beautiful scenery, peaceful wild life, and ultra secluded...who could ask for much more? Perfect blend of medium, long, and super long holes, lots of trees & rocks, and some shots along the waterfront. A number of different tee shots are required and available. Great elevation changes and rugged terrain.

Cons:

Uhh...hmm...nope, none.

Other Thoughts:

What an amazing course. Warm and sunny day, but I'm glad I wore gators and pants. This course tests your distance, accuracy, and putting skills. It's certainly a more difficult course, but great shots are rewarded. These 36-holes at New Hogan were an absolute steal for $4 on a weekday! These are among the highest grades I've ever given a course.
=================
Uniqueness: A+ (similar to Stafford, but with better lake views)
Difficulty: A (trees, rocks, elevation, wind)
Fun Factor: A+ (amazing views, super fun holes, some birdy opps)
Aesthetics: A+ (awesome course layout in beautiful terrain, next to the water)
---------------------
Overall: A+
Was this review helpful? Yes No
1 2
Steve D.
Experience: 3 played 3 reviews
4.00 star(s)

Play this course 2+ years drive by

Reviewed: Played on:Apr 20, 2013 Played the course:2-4 times

Pros:

Several beautiful basket placements on this course. This side is very challenging. Great variation of shots required.

Cons:

This course still has dirt tees.

Other Thoughts:

The wind on this side is sketchy, bring your A game. Several new long holes really open this course up. This side used every disc in my bag. Well marked and easy to navigate, this side gets my vote if I could only play one of the courses. Great job with new layout Hogan Team!
Was this review helpful? Yes No
3 1
Magiken
Gold level trusted reviewer
Experience: 14.7 years 74 played 74 reviews
3.00 star(s)

West is Best 2+ years drive by

Reviewed: Played on:Oct 21, 2012 Played the course:2-4 times

Pros:

• Very good shot variety
• Very nice views
• Interesting wildlife here and there
• Tees are better defined than they were
• Restrooms and water nearby with additional facilities (e.g. BBQ, fishing, cleaning station, etc...)

Cons:

• Tees are still dirt
• A little tricky to navigate in spots

Other Thoughts:

Tips:
• Bring a map

Random Thoughts:
So obviously you need to read both the East and West reviews to know what you're getting out here and since there are two courses I felt like I was cheating the course by reviewing them separately. I'd rather see this listed as one big course because that's basically what it is. But having said that, my thoughts on the West course are that it's far better than the East course. There is a much greater shot variety, from long difficult holes to ace runs, hyzers, anhyzers, slight tunnels, protected baskets and all the fun in between. And the views just blow the East side away, making the whole round far more interesting and rewarding. And seriously, #17 is still one of the best/funnest holes I've ever played. You can not beat an all downhill 700 footer that finishes on a beach. It's a beautiful shot and still home to my farthest drive ever. The one hole I have a concern about is #11. IF, I said IF, the water ever returns to where the waterline is, this hole will be damn near unplayable, but again, I have no idea how likely that is. But as is, it's a very long, challenging, but fun hole. And I'd like to say again, that this is a nice destination course. Due to its location, I suspect it's not convenient for anyone, but I enjoy loading up the BBQ supplies and heading here. With all the amenities and the atmosphere/views, it makes for a fun relaxing day.

Bottom Line:
Definitely the jewel of the two courses, and if you're going to play both I'd advise playing the East first so you can save the best for last. Kudos to the course designers on taking an already interesting course and making better. Looking forward to the continued improvements. And again, I'd definitely review this course higher if it were one course. It's doing the course a disservice to split them up. So, of course, now go read the East review.
Was this review helpful? Yes No
7 0
jasonandsharon
Gold level trusted reviewer
Experience: 39.9 years 498 played 66 reviews
4.00 star(s)

Almost Epic Course 2+ years drive by

Reviewed: Played on:Oct 8, 2012 Played the course:5+ times

Pros:

Lots of great shot selection. Lots of land. Most holes range from 250 to 500 feet with hole #17 coming in at over 700+. Absolutely beautiful course in late winter early spring. The land has lots of oaks scattered over the property with rocks sticking out of the ground throughout. All of the baskets are in great shape. The course has several water hazards along the lake shore when the lake is high enough. Most holes are strategically placed in the middle of tree groves or boulders so that even the shortest holes are challenging.

Cons:

This course can get very rough in the summer months, with lots of weeds and stickers. Wear long pants, boots and gators. $4 to get into area, not that bad considering you get 36 wonderful holes and a beautiful lake. Watch for rattlesnakes in summer.

Other Thoughts:

This is a beautiful scenic piece of property to put a course on. This course is very similar in how it plays and looks to stafford, skyline, black butte or casitas: beautiful CA wilderness areas. This course tends to dry out faster than those other courses so has a shorter optimal time to play, but is still very playable in summer just prepare.
Was this review helpful? Yes No
Top