i just realized the % is 55 not 60. that means Dave242 is only about 55 upvotes away from jumping straight to diamond.
For as many reviews as Dave wrote, a great many are lacking substance. They're simply his numbering system. Nothing more. It wasn't until the end where he started adding substance to his reviews. If his poor reviews were removed, all 100 - 150 of them, he would have easily been Gold or Diamond a long time ago.