Standard DGCR thread, Does this count?

[snappyfingers]

Talk about "sticking" your shot....

 

[Triflusal]

I voted no it's not in because i am my own unique snowflake

 

[Skulboy]

My friend missed a putt, got mad, threw a sidearm from 10 feet away with his nightshift boss and that was the result.

If he already missed his putt then threw another disc, then it's a practice putt which is not allowed. He gets a warning and an added stroke next time he whips an extra disc at the basket.
I could be wrong, just trying to be technical.

 

[billnchristy]

Way to ruin an expensive disc Mr. Anger Management.

 

[fbj2361]

i would say that it is in considering that it is touching the chains

 

[vonDrehle]

I would say that shot is in. The way I read the rule is the shot counts if it gets held up or wedged while inside the basket and that one is definitely inside.

 

[shinypickle]

it counts

 

[kw83028]

^So he attempted to abuse that innocent basket and it FOUGHT BACK?

LMAO!! I say it's in....

 

[rusch_bag]

If he already missed his putt then threw another disc, then it's a practice putt which is not allowed. He gets a warning and an added stroke next time he whips an extra disc at the basket.
I could be wrong, just trying to be technical.

You are over thinking this. I was just wondering what would be the ruling if this did happen in a tournament. This obviously was in a casual round as no one would do that during a tournament.

 

[medicinalfunk]

I voted no it's not in because i am my own unique snowflake

now you're gettin it

 

[Cgkdisc]

It's good. Disc is supported by the chains and it entered the target below the bottom of the chain support and above the top of the basket rim.

 

[chrishysell]

It's good. Disc is supported by the chains and it entered the target below the bottom of the chain support and above the top of the basket rim.

Not necessarily. I now have my doubts. Was that shot thrown from the proper lie or from where he missed the previous putt? We need more info.

 

[John Rock]

The "S" hook had to be purchased separately so it could be argued that it is a part of the "chain support system" which is different than the chains themselves. The disc in the pic is NOT supported by a chain (a series of interlocked metal rings). If we're tightening up the hole out rules, this should be clarified by the rules comittee.

Also, no warning on a practice throw. Auto stroke.

 

[Triflusal]

now you're gettin it

I wonder who else did

 

[agent_peebody]

In.

but only if it's a Halex Mid Range 160 GRAM disc.

 

[rusch_bag]

Not necessarily. I now have my doubts. Was that shot thrown from the proper lie or from where he missed the previous putt? We need more info.

It was during a cas round it was not his real shot. For our case, assume it was during a tournament and it was a legit shot. (I don't know why you would ever throw a driver from that close that hard at the basket, but who cares)

 

[billnchristy]

In that case yeah its in and your card hates you.

 

[JR Stengele]

I would count it in and thank my lucky stars. Amazing shot!

 

[mashnut]

In.

but only if it's a cereal bowl pretending to be a disc.

FTFY

 

[ArcheType]

FTFY

haha! :clap: