You're also forgetting that your ratings is conglomerate formula based upon a full year's worth of events. You can "say" she never beats those people, but within the last year Sarah's finished first at the Swine in Thailand (beat Paige by 8), Nantucket (beat Cat by 6), GMC (beat Kristin by 5, Rebecca by 6, Paige by 10, and Cat by 20), and the Hall of Fame (beat Paige by 4, Cat by 9).
Pudding.
And as far as who you "See" as better. Well she;s rated 4 points above Henna and Eveliina, who are probably 8-10 years younger. Four-tenths of a stroke per round would allow you to use your on eye test to say who's better. But it is still awfully close regardless.
Sometimes these types of comments stem from the fact that a lot of guys don't want to see these women as just as good, if not better than, the high MA1 player.