Pros:
The layout was spacious on the front nine, with quite a few grip 'n rip opportunities (#1, #2, and #9 especially).
Hole 5 is gnarly. You have to either tomahawk over the trees on the left to a totally blind basket (despite what the tee sign says, you can't drive long and double back) or drive short and wide right to set up your second, and the saw palmetto is thick.
All the baskets and tees are brand new and in good shape.
Once you throw your drive on Hole 9, you leave Florida. The hills in this park were utilized on the back nine... uphill shots, wooded shots, poke 'n hope shots, downhill shots, and blind shots. I'd think even seasoned players might find the back nine rough.
The lines on some of the holes are very tricky and really present risk vs. reward opportunities.
#10 through #15 might be the toughest stretch of holes in the Tampa Bay area. The sheer drops on these holes really make you stop and think. I would make sure you have a drop and stop putter for all of these holes.
The disc golf course is mostly segregated from the rest of the park, so the only pedestrians are occasional hikers.
Like other reviewers, I consider the $2 entry fee a plus for various reasons. This is a beautiful park and is extremely well maintained. I didn't see a single piece of trash in the entire park.
We went on a weekday and there was one other group on the entire course. Very nature-y and nice and quiet.
Large playground and very clean restrooms close to the first tee (but go before you throw, because a round here takes a while).
Cons:
Some of the lower lying areas of the park seem susceptible to flooding. The tee for #2 was very wet and the fairways for #7 and #8 were wet and muddy. This isn't really the parks fault and not a fault in the design, but it does stink when you can't play a hole due to course conditions.
Bugs are a big issue, especially on the back nine. Bring some strong Off with you.
Some of the underbrush on the back nine is also extremely thick, so long pants might not be a bad idea, despite the heat. There are also lots of spiders in the undergrowth, so be careful when retrieving discs.
One big issue I had on the back nine was hanging twigs and limbs. The ceilings are low on some shots and you just can't see every single little twig hanging down from up there. I got pwned on a couple of short shots by tiny little limbs.
The course doesn't come back to the parking lot at all until you finish.
Other Thoughts:
Spotters here are extremely helpful, especially on the back nine. If you have time and a friend with you, go out and spot each others throws. I'm sure my buddy and I would have lost discs if we didn't do this.
Bug spray, bug spray, bug spray... And a lot of water; a round here takes a while.
If you're not into climbing and hiking, this course may not be for you. I'm 26 and in great shape and this course really took it out of me.
--------------------------
Update - Played for the second time on 2/15/20, and I'm dropping my rating from a 4.0 to a 3.0. I considered going even lower but I want to be fair. Three-fourths of the course is still good, but there are a few serious problems that I noticed on my newest play-through. I'll list them in order of significance to me.
1) Holes 11 through 15 are in much worse shape than the first time I played and 14 is not what I consider playable. All these holes are lined with disgusting, mold and fungus infested swamp water. Most of the slopes have eroded to the point of being dangerous to step on, and the overgrowth is starting to take over these fairways. These holes no longer have lines. #13 still has no tee pad and in the summer I can see #12, #13, and even #14 being completely inundated by water. I played in the peak of dry season and this water was flat out gross. The mosquitoes in summer have to be horrific.The tee pad for #14 is also completely voided underneath by erosion and this tee will collapse very soon, hopefully without someone standing on it.
2) The erosion has become dangerous. Some of the slopes you have to climb have gotten so steep you can easily slip and fall. Tree roots are exposed and you could easily trip and injure yourself or roll an ankle on a root. And the slopes are all soft sand and not solid ground; a mound of dirt gave out from under my friend's foot on #9 and he almost fell...not okay at all.
3) We came on a pretty busy weekend day and there were at least fifty people wandering on the back nine holes. Kids playing with baskets and climbing trees and people just walking around, oblivious to the disc golf course. There is no signage telling people there is even a course back there despite there being a picnic area and parking lot lining #9's fairway.With the back nine being so overgrown, the risk of someone getting hit by a ricocheting shot is extremely high.
4) Hole #5 is so badly overgrown there is no line to the basket anymore. The pin should be moved or clearing should be done.
It doesn't seem to me that the course is being kept up as well as it could be, and with Picnic Island being much more up-kept and being more of a fair challenge, this isn't someplace I'll be coming back to unless changes are made.
I feel a fair design change would be to place a second basket with a colored band on it at the base of the hill on #9 and allow for play of the front nine, allowing players to ignore the elevation completely, and back nine, and play a simpler nine-hole layout.