Pros:
- two practice baskets
- blue banded Innova DISCatchers in good shape
- fun for a quicker, more casual round than Brown Deer or Dretzka
- concrete tees
- newer full color tee signs with maps
- benches at each tee, garbage cans throughout course
- three pin positions for most holes
- rough is generally forgiving
- holes 10 and 11 have challenging elevated baskets while throwing downhill towards Milwaukee River
- generally well maintained park with mature trees
- ample parking
Cons:
- mostly flat and fairly open
- lots of holes play a bit close to street and walking paths
- some navigation gets fairly confusing, particularly holes 16-20
- some minor backtracking between holes
- a few very long walks on back half of course between holes (11-12, for example)
- would be cool to use wooded area after 11 down by the river more
- fairways for 18 and 19 are too close to each other
- no pars on tee signs
Other Thoughts:
Estabrook was the 3rd Milwaukee course I played, and was my least favorite. Now, that's not a very fair assessment when Dretzka and Brown Deer were the first two - I think almost anyone would agree they are objectively better courses in almost every way. Estabrook is still a solid course, though it's probably not my favorite style.
Where Estabrook shines is if you are looking for a quicker, more casual round. There is very little elevation change here, which is a con for me, but it does mean it's a lot less strenuous and your round moves more quickly. Yes, it is still 20 holes, but hardly any of them eclipse 300 ft. This is a pretty quick course to play as long as you stay out of trouble.
I've seen this course described by a few reviewers as "technical". This is not how I would describe it compared to the other top-tier Milwaukee courses. It is fairly open, with some tree obstacles to be sure, but not a wooded course by any means, with the exception of a few holes. Most shots can be made with fairway drivers or lower speed discs, but you will have to do some shot selection and shaping to score well.
I think my favorite holes here were 10 and 11. Both have baskets that are elevated a bit higher on their poles and they are mounted at the start of a downward slope. You can see the Milwaukee River beyond, but it's not really in play as a hazard unless you REALLY roll a disc down the hill. However, these are tough shots with a big risk if you don't lay up near the basket. They are some of the better challenges on the course.
The equipment here is in good shape and the tee signs are newer. My main con here is the navigation and playing too close to roads/walking paths. Navigation starts out very straightforward, but gets pretty confusing around hole 11 or so. There is a really long walk to hole 12, followed by some backtracking to hole 13. From here it's ok again until hole 16. This is the weirdest part of the course: the tees for 16, 17, 18, and 20 all throw the same direction and are all generally visible from the same area. For the life of me, I don't understand why they couldn't turn 1-2 of these holes around so you go back and forth a bit more instead of backtracking. You hop around between these tees unsure which is which, and it's fairly confusing.
This is a very respectable course I'd be happy to have in my community but it didn't have any real wow factor for me. The park is nicely maintained but there are much better courses nearby. The $5 to play is a great deal when you consider how many Milwaukee courses it covers. I'm not sure I'd pay it solely to play here, but would in a heartbeat at Dretzka Park and Brown Deer Park, both of which are a short drive. If you're already in Milwaukee for those two, this is a respectable #3 to play if your legs will still allow.
If you are playing in the fall, watch out for the black walnuts everywhere on the ground. I felt like I was just asking to roll an ankle here.