Pros:
I can't think of a more appropriate place to review than French Creek for my 50th write-up. It was one of the first courses I played and got to embarrass myself on, heh, and subsequently hated initially. Didn't help that I left a prized disc on some fenced-off utility shed from a bad tree hit'n'skip by #4 my first time out. I also avoided reviewing a course so far above my skill level til now.
There are a few star holes, especially on the first loop (#1-7) but otherwise the holes individually become a blur. I just played yesterday, fifth time out, and for the life of me, I can scarcely remember any hole's layout specific after #8.
It's not a dig at the course either. Comparable level courses like Green Lane, I can remember every hole, a series of different challenges and constantly going up and down to reach them. French Creek is much more relaxed, less out to impress you with variety, just like a smooth hike in the woods where you happen to throw discs. And that's sometimes exactly the type of higher level course I want, easier on the body while still being difficult.
Everytime I come here, I enjoy it more and more, mixing the silver (short) and gold baskets and taking challenges one at a time as they come. I don't just measure my improvement over the years by distances here, but the fact I can mostly avoid the sheer number of trees now and reach silver in one shot. Wasn't like that the first four years. The nice thing is it's tall (and so, dark before dusk) forest with very little heavy brush, so off-course bright-colored discs are typically found quickly.
Honestly, if I were to change anything, it would simply be the numbering, 8-18 loop would come first and 1-7 later, just to end on a more memorable final stretch than have it right up front. Like a hike with a final destination.
If you're more of a community courser in distances or openness, give the silver baskets a try until you find your legs on this course.
+Holes 1, 3, tunnel 4, 5, and 12 are pretty good. #3 is the star of the course imo.
Cons:
The ground is really rocky. Like a million head sized rocks jutting out of the ground. Not for everyone.
The insects really love to nip here. Repellent is much more a must than normal courses, probably because of the lake.
Other than that, I didn't really have much of a problem with the course as it plays. There are annoyances, the gold baskets are really bright, but the silver baskets are a dull graying zinc coating that camoflage into the background and really need to be brightened up.
Navigation can also be a pain. Silver baskets have arrows but the golds don't for some reason. Most of the time the next area is obvious but it still would have helped out at points. Speaking of which, Silver has no finished course map on Udisc, Gold does is not the default "Main", which is some weird hybrid averaging between the two that left me confused initially.
It's also a shame that the mega-pool is closed for 2022, it'd be nice to play this place and then cool off afterwards.
Other Thoughts:
Course loops 1-7 on one side of the parking lot and 8 starts way up top (where you drive in) and ends at 18 on bottom. 13-18 is loop within that.
Terrain: OOOo - Very good. Extremely rocky Pennsylvania forest at its finest with elevation, but not in your face about it.
Execution: OOOO - Excellent. Over time, I've seen the changes that indicate this place has an active club that made it the course it is today rather than one that stagnates after opening.
Upkeep: OOOo. Very good. Good tees, signs, but silver baskets and some navigation needs work.
Difficulty: OOOo - The amount of trees makes good shots worth something and bring consequences to bad ones.
Fun Factor: OOOO - I unexpectantly have more fun here every time I play and get better.
Crowded: XXx. Hm, not here enough to accurately gauge but a bit less than average given the off-hours I go to. The fact that French Creek State Park is pretty much a drive just to get in keeps it less busy than it should be. But there's often players/groups about.
Overall: OOOO - I think this place is a 3.75 but I will bump it up.