Pros:
The reviews are 5 or more years old - time for a fresh take.
+ Paver tees, very good tee signs, old but still catchy DisCatchers
+ The biggest feature of Joralemon is the variety: there are park holes, there are lightly wooded holes, and there are deep woods, elevation-changing, rock formation-dodging holes. There's some water, there's some marked OB, there are short and long par 3's, and some pretty massive par 4's. It's got pretty much everything spread over its 38 holes
+ Equally important, the holes are very well-designed, and they make great use of the natural features (especially rock formations used to shape fairways, guard greens and raise baskets)
+ If you don't want to play all 38 holes straight through ("All of J"), Joralemon has organized a series of 18's using different sets of holes ("North", "South", "West" and "East"). These layouts range from "Technical" to "Highly Technical." Holes #14 - #29 play across the road from the main park. They're in deep woods with a lot of elevation change, and the more of these holes you include in your round, the more technically challenging it will be.
+ Memorable Hole: #7 is a 269' par 3 that uses rock outcroppings on either side to shape the fairway, slightly bending right, and narrowing as you near the basket
+ Memorable Hole: #13 is a big (567'), straight par 4 across an open field with OB woods on the right, then through a narrow gate of trees to a protected green with small trees in front and water on the left and behind
+ Memorable Hole: #20 is a 220' downhill par 3 through thick woods. Pretty straight, but narrow lines. And an OB swamp 15 feet behind the basket
+ Memorable Hole: #22 is a steep uphill 217' par 3 that turns the the right with a rock outcropping in the center of the throwing lane at the very top of the hill. Devious good hole.
+ Memorable Hole: #38 is a massive (795') par 4 with a swampy area for the first 200'+. It then goes slightly uphill and turns a bit to the left, to eventually reach a basket on the right that's perched atop a rock. Amazing finishing hole that asks for every bit of power you have left
Cons:
- If there are white (short) tees as indicated here and in uDisc, they're only white flags - and I didn't see many of them. Not a course for beginners
- Next tee navigation is almost entirely absent. There are a few old wooden arrows here and there, but the first time playing experience is really compromised by time spent wandering around in the woods, especially on the east side of the road. If you're playing alone and it's your first time at Joralemon, be prepared to backtrack a lot.
- Some of the holes on the "highly technical" portion just feel like baskets stuck in the woods. The "fairways" are narrow valleys through deep woods (I swear the fairways illustrated on the tee signs are just imaginary). Much of #14 - #29 is so severe that I bet a lot of players avoid them and play the South and West layouts
Other Thoughts:
~ If you're playing All of J or the North or East layouts, don't even think about using a cart. Holes 14 - 29 (rocky, thickly wooded, elevation change) will make you want to dump it in a ravine and carry your discs in your hands.
~ I wonder how chaotic traffic gets on busy days because of the multiple layouts sharing holes in different orders. As they connect you might suddenly find yourself behind a bunch of groups that you didn't even know were on the course
~ A rock-solid "4.0" - an excellent and well-designed course, but limited to only one basket and one actual tee per hole. And it's surprising how poor the wayfinding is. Not a problem for regular players, but a couple of dozen well-placed arrows would really help out the first timers. The DGCR average is 4.22 - and the crowd of 52 reviewers gets it right