Pros:
Great layout. Winds tight around the hill.
Easy to find next tee, not much distance between them. Limited back tracking.
Deceptively short holes that present plenty of challenges with numerous obstacles. Very fun but can be frustrating. Keeps things very interesting.
Bring all of your shots, you will need them!
Awesome elevation changes come in to play in a big way. Uphill, down hill, side of the hill, etc.
Plenty of benches at tees and a few picnic tables (Thanks Marty!)
Water available by tee 18
Fairways mowed and maintained
Concrete Pads
Friendly people
Few non-discers on paths
Beautiful view from tee 18
Cons:
No trash cans
One portajohn in parking lot
Can be buggy and boggy/wet with right conditions (not an issue on day I played)
One or two holes can over lap with a an overpowered or bad throw. Can get hit with disc if not paying attention.
Very unforgiving, old school baskets. Nearly sunk a 80 foot Roc shot for birdie and it got spit out in a big way. I got Oxbowed!
A few picnic tables were falling apart.
Other Thoughts:
Loved this course, can't wait to play it again when I make it back to NY. New baskets, trashcans, and a bathroom is what prevents me from giving Oxbow Falls a five rating. That is it. Very challenging and requires accuracy, finesse, and strategy to par. If you are passing through anywhere nearby, do not pass up a chance to experience Oxbow Falls!