Pros:
- some good elevation change incorporated
- good mix of open and wooded holes
- Innova DISCatcher baskets in good shape, with hole numbers
- tee signs with full color maps with current pin position
- multiple pin positions per hole
- concrete tees with brick extensions behind
- benches and garbage cans throughout course
- area mostly devoted to disc golf
- wooded areas contain mature trees and are somewhat picturesque
- well maintained/mowed park
- longer concrete tees on final 6 holes
- notable length with most holes over 250 ft
- great water hazard on hole 24
Cons:
- a few places where built in stairs/bridges could have been helpful
- a lot of tees are sunken and showing their age
- a little light on amenities, no practice basket
- in fall, thick leaves on the ground can make finding discs hard
- could use next tee signs to aid navigation in places
- a few safety hazards playing near/across access road
- can be muddy in some low-lying areas
- would be nice to incorporate large lake on the property more
Other Thoughts:
It seems I'm in the minority scoring Rogers Lakewood park a 3.5. This is a very respectable course and all of the 4s are warranted... I think the difference for me is mostly subjective and this course just didn't wow me quite to the 4 level.
There is lots of good here - numerous holes that don't tend to feel repetitive, a good mix of wooded and open, and generally good equipment. I'd probably prefer a few more of the tight, wooded holes, but there is a mix of something for everyone here. The park is nice, though the scenery is nothing to write home about. I wish the large lake had been incorporated into the course more; it really only comes into play on holes 1, 2 and 24. I have visions of the Lakeside course at Selah Ranch here in terms of potential, though sadly that course is no longer with us.
Note that the map on DGCR as of today is not completely accurate and doesn't show the water carry on hole 24. It looks like some things have been reworked. The concrete tees for holes 19-24 are newer and larger, and these holes add some good variety to the course, though this is definitely a long course you will need some energy for, more in the "hiking boots" category - at least, as much as Indiana gets into that category.
I'll be updating the course info as offseason parking is no longer free - it is $3, but with no fee to actually play the course this is a bargain. There is tons of parking and in November, the park is quite empty. The leaves on the ground are definitely a factor at this time of year, so just be prepared. In addition, the wind can be a significant factor here on the more open holes, both for how your disc flies as well as comfort. With a misty wind at sunrise in November, the first few holes were a bit rough for me.
This course demands a decent level of accuracy as well as a decent arm for distance, with some uphill and downhill shots as part of that. Usually, I'm fairly close to par, or maybe slightly under; not the case here. I was +13 over 24 holes - this is definitely a tougher course. I noted the most significant elevation change on holes 13 and 15.
Navigation was ok but definitely could have been better with some next tee signs. I'm sure there are bathrooms somewhere in this park, but not right by the disc golf course. There were numerous holes throwing over the entrance road, or infrequently-used access roads. I think the risk here is low; I don't like it in terms of design, but it's more something to be aware of than a real issue.
Overall, this course is definitely worth hitting. It's not a destination at all, and heading to Lemon Lake is probably more worth your while if you're coming from a notable distance. I came for the day from Chicago and hit this course, Indiana Dunes NP, and several niners. I think it's worth the day trip and is a very respectable course for the area. It's not quite a 4 for me, but NW Indiana doesn't have tons of epic courses, so this is still one of the better ones.