Pros:
`
*** REVISED AND UPDATED: 2024 ****
+ Both courses at Tyler have multiple pin positions and/or tees, so over time the layout of every hole can be set up one of three ways (and every tee has an indicator of which basket is in use that day). This variety is the strong suit at Tyler, and the looks and challenges of most holes will vary greatly. A few just add distance, but most of them include some change of required angle or consideration of elevation change. Several add the challenge of raised baskets perched over gulleys, in groves of trees, or behind additional mandos.
+ The man made "bunkers" (log piles) are the stuff of legends: lining fairways, creating gaps off the tee, protecting greens. The amount of repurposed forest lumber on this course is impressive
+ Excellent Mach 7 baskets (with clearly visible hole numbers atop). All tees are concrete or pavers. The layout crosses itself in several places, but the wayfinding signage is excellent.
+ There are a number of great holes at Tyler East, and a few of them are simply perfect:
Hole #8 is straight, wooded and narrow, with the river flowing entirely along the right side past the trees (the water isn't so much a direct danger, but the possibility of a treekick looms). The variety of pin placements is what makes this hole so great. Short (256') is gradually uphill, placed at the edge of a steep drop off a ledge. Middle (335") is past the ledge and down on the gully to the left, placed up against a quarry wall. Long (505') is straight away, 200' beyond he ledge and through the gully with a narrow fairway (and the river on the right). I wished there were three baskets in place, as I would have enjoyed playing it all three ways
Hole #15 is also thickly wooded, and it's downhill, with narrow lines. All three pin positions are straight ahead, but the Long (460') requires two perfect shots for a chance at birdie. The drive has to finish safely in a tight zone, and your second shot has to make it through a narrowing window, while avoiding streams across and to the right. Any error can easily mean bogey or worse.
+ If you haven't played Tyler, you'll be surprised by the wide open holes 16 and 17. Deep grass along the fairway marks OB, but you'll still have a few chances to air it out. Then, hole 18 puts you back in the woods for a steep uphill finisher.
.
Cons:
.
- The tee signs are impressive: hand painted with extensive drawings and distances for every pin position, but they're showing their age and some are becoming hard to read. One small complaint is the lack of signage at the short tees. You have to go to the long tees to find signage - and estimate the change in distance by playing from the forward tee. Easy workarounds: all lengths are available on online scorecard maintained by the Bucks County Disc Golf Alliance, and approximate lengths are indicated on uDisc.
.
Other Thoughts:
.
~ Fair amount of walking between holes (some of it pretty rugged woods trails) can make for 90+ minute rounds, even when playing solo.
~ "Somehat cart friendly" means Somewhat NOT, too - especially with a few hole transitions. In my opinion, a cart is not worth the trouble here.
Given the challenge, variety, upkeep and natural beauty, I asked myself how Tyler East is not a perfect 5.0. The layout is missing any par 5's, and there aren't many left-to-right shaped shots required. It's perfect for "intermediate and above" players, but there's really not a good way to bring those with lesser skills. And as much as I admire the variety presented by multiple placements, I still look for multiple baskets at the very best courses, so you can play different layouts during the same visit. The average rating here is 4.55, and I agree.
Thanks to designer Joe Mela, and The Bucks County Disc Golf Alliance for this beautiful and challenging course
.