If it's in that range where I am probably getting a 2, CANNOT turn it into a 3, and it's a bonus to get it in 1, then it's a step/jump lofty putt so that it settles down within 10-15' for a guaranteed tap in.
If it's in the farther end of that range where there's such a tiny chance of me sinking it and I'd be straining my step putt, then I'll aim at the ground and lay up (often with a putter FH). If you are laying up, decide on that and follow the plan. Aim where you want to hit the ground, don't just look at the basket and try to get it "close to the basket". That's a recipe for babying it in the air and fading/stalling out, or other things.
Also, if you decide on an approach shot, just because it's open straight doesn't mean you shouldn't hyzer it in a bit to help your range if that is comfortable for you.
Really in this range it's all about comfort. So experiment with all the options and figure out what is consistent for you. Just never more 3's than 1's.