hugheshilton
* Ace Member *
I guess I'll give this a shot..
First off, Anthon's are a very expensive collectors item now.. not something you're going to use as a thrower.. but maybe you have expensive taste.. Philo's are nice, IMO.. They are all a little lighter weight, 167-169g i believe, They are less stable than the new stock runs and are a little more gummy and grippy. The new stock runs are beef cakes, and stiff. The Brinster's are Very beefy.. They seem like the stiffest of the plastic molds I've tried.. Hope this helps some.
^ This seems mostly right to me. I would add that some of the current run of Star (with the embossed word "Destroyer" on the underside rather than pen) are actually a little less overstable than the previous McBeth run. The max weights are still pretty beefy, but a little lighter and they can be much more workable. I have a 163g that was actually quite flippy out of the box. Anyway, stock-stamped Star Destroyers of all weights can be all over the place in stability, so you want to buy them in person if possible. For less overstability, you want to look for lower PLH, flatter, and a straighter wing (as opposed to more concave).
Personally I really like buying max weight GStar Destroyers. They are straight to fade with good glide out of the box (at least for my ~400 feet of power), and they can handle wind pretty well without being meat hooks like the max weight Stars. As they beat in, they develop a little turn and then stay in the sweet spot for quite a while before getting understable enough to be more max distance type discs.
Pro's are also pretty nice. They seem to start out a little more overstable than the GStars, but beat in faster.
I have very little experience with Champion. Not too many people seem to love them from what I've seen. The one Champ that I threw very much wasn't really all that great. It had some turn out of the box like a seasoned Star or GStar, but it didn't have nearly as much glide. It would have a nice looking flight, but still not get as much distance as my other Destroyers.