Playing 51 usually just results in $5 making its rounds back and forth between people. You notice no real net winnings.
Change it up to a running bet the length of a season or summer or something. Count up all the wins, and at the end when everthing becomes a push but the guy who has the most. Then, just split his extra wins (which were not pushed by every second place win) among all the players in on the bet. For example, say you have 10 people all in on this. Everyone gets at ace, but one guy gets 3 aces and another gets 4. The guy with 4 has a net win of 1. All other 9 players split that one $5 net win with him.
Better yet, make it something like a steak dinner or something. Go out and celebrate the season as a group and the net winner gets his dinner picked up by everyone else. We do this with total scores. Me and 4 other guys that play all the time keep track of all our scores (in joint rounds) throughout the summer season. After Labor Day we have a feast which the winner particpates for free.
Change it up to a running bet the length of a season or summer or something. Count up all the wins, and at the end when everthing becomes a push but the guy who has the most. Then, just split his extra wins (which were not pushed by every second place win) among all the players in on the bet. For example, say you have 10 people all in on this. Everyone gets at ace, but one guy gets 3 aces and another gets 4. The guy with 4 has a net win of 1. All other 9 players split that one $5 net win with him.
Better yet, make it something like a steak dinner or something. Go out and celebrate the season as a group and the net winner gets his dinner picked up by everyone else. We do this with total scores. Me and 4 other guys that play all the time keep track of all our scores (in joint rounds) throughout the summer season. After Labor Day we have a feast which the winner particpates for free.