Community is always my first choice.
Ditto. At this point I feel like I know Justin (owner of Community) personally. The majority of my purchases are made with him.
I try to split between Justin and my local retailer. I occasionally place an order with Marshall St if I can swing the $50+ to get free shipping - awesome selection and prices. Disc Golf Center is a distant third for me, but I do order from them, too, once in a blue moon. Their free shipping is indeed slow compared to others, and their prices not as good (anyone remember when they temporarily jacked Westside Tournament up to $19 or something like that?).