Your Highest Thumber Course and Rating

[Donovan]

I think it would be interesting to see what type of ratings you gave a course that got you the most positive thumbers to date. I would think most people would have 5-rated type courses, but mine isn't that way at all. So let's see how this turns out.

Course Name - Location - Rating You Gave It - # of :thmbup: at Time of Post

Here is mine:

Andrew Brown Park - Coppell, TX - 1.0 - 25

 

[bcr123psu]

Nockamixon State Park - Quakertown, PA - 4.0 - 21

 

[billnchristy]

Crooked Creek, Chapin SC - 4.5 - 12

 

[Dave242]

Idlewild - 3.5 - 42
Abbey Resort - 0 - 22

 

[sillybizz]

Mine: Horning's Hideout: Meadow Ridge Rating Given: 5 Thumbs up: 10 Thumbs down: 4

I forgot paragraphs on this one too!

 

[fifteen]

Wow, my numbers doesn't compare to y'all.

Maxwell Park DGC - 3.0 - 6 Thumbs up and 0 thumbs down.

Got a couple with 5 thumbs up.

 

[volklgirl]

Flip City - 5 - 38:thmbup:, 1:thmbdown:

School Section Lake - 0 - 17:thmbup:, 0:thmbdown:

 

[Danger]

Coyote Point at Lake Casitas - 5.0 - 20:thmbup: 1:thmbdown:



Interesting study

 

[nygfaninva]

Prospect Park, Bklyn NY- 3.0-19 Thumbs Up / 1 Thumb Down

 

[zenbot]

I rated Conejo Valley YMCA a 0. I got 17:thmbup: and 3:thmbdown:.

Interesting note: This is my most thumbs up on a review as well as my most thumbs down on a review.

 

[DSCJNKY]

Renny Gold - 4.5 - 16 :thmbup:- 0 :thmbdown:
Ski Sunrise - 4.5 - 16 :thmbup: - 0 :thmbdown:

Both fantastic courses on opposite ends of the country.
DSCJNKY

 

[chiefcastor]

Black Bear Park - Hoffman Estates, IL - 3.0 - 4 up 1 down...

Most of my reviews only have 1 thumb... seems like chicagoland people don't use the site much.

 

[craigd]

Deer Lick Park 14 :thmbup:
White Oak Park 14 :thmbup:

 

[craigd]

Deer Lick Park 14 :thmbup:
White Oak Park 14 :thmbup:

I forgot to mention,
Deer Lick I rated a 3.5
White Oak I rated a 3.5

And I have one :thmbdown: on Deer lick too.

 

[mashnut]

My two biggest are Flip City with 26 up and 8 down (my highest totals for each). and Idlewild with 20 up and 1 down, and those are my only two 5 disc rated courses. At the opposite end of the spectrum, two of my three 0 disc reviews also somehow managed to make it to double digit thumbs, Crosslin Park with 11 and Highway 70 Sports Complex with 10, that's always seemed a little odd to me.

Black Bear Park - Hoffman Estates, IL - 3.0 - 4 up 1 down...

Most of my reviews only have 1 thumb... seems like chicagoland people don't use the site much.

Yeah, a lot of my chicago area reviews don't get many votes, just the way it is.

 

[harr0140]

Charlie Vettiner 18 - 0 Yeah!

 

[harr0140]

My two biggest are Flip City with 26 up and 8 down (my highest totals for each). and Idlewild with 20 up and 1 down, and those are my only two 5 disc rated courses. At the opposite end of the spectrum, two of my three 0 disc reviews also somehow managed to make it to double digit thumbs, Crosslin Park with 11 and Highway 70 Sports Complex with 10, that's always seemed a little odd to me.




Yeah, a lot of my chicago area reviews don't get many votes, just the way it is.

Some of my low rated courses have gotten me some good thumbs ( I think because I saved someone the hassle (which happens to be why I will play whatever course I am near once) as well as being the first reviewer also brings in the votes (at least initially).

 

[Jukeshoe]

Rogers Lakewood in Valparaiso, IN 8 up, 1 down. Gave it a 4.5 which I stand by.

 

[Donovan]

Well, this is a bit more random than I suspected.

 

[optidiscic]

Woodshed 21 up..benefits of the top 10 I suspect and i have 4 with 2 thumbs down FEW in PA, Yetter in PA, Tyler SP in PA, and Borderland in Mass I gave it a 4. Funny I have no idea why I got thumbed down..but I think anonymous feedback would really help the site. I don't know if I made a mistake or if they are just pissed off locals?