Pros:
A good course in a mostly-open park, with a layout that makes the best use of a creek cutting through the property.
+ As others have noted, the course makes great use of the water. There are five holes where you're throwing over water - but the extra challenge of this layout is that the placement of the water on the hole varies - sometimes it's on your teeshot, sometimes on your approach, and sometimes on your upshot. Sometimes you have to cross it with your disc going left, sometimes with your disc going right
+ Concrete tees, good signage and baskets. Clean park, and the course appears to be in its own dedicated area. I don't remember seeing more than a few walkers
+ A few holes have additional, long baskets. I didn't play to those, but I'm sure they make the course more attractive for regular play
+ Judging by reading through earlier reviews, this course is getting regular improvements (signs, tees, layout tweaks, etc.)
+ A special shout-out to Hole # 14 for it's devious challenges. It's a pretty tame looking 300ish hole with the water along the left hidden behind deep and thick foliage. There's a hard left turn at the end down to a basket in creekside trees. From the tee, the open fairway tilts increasingly down toward the creek, so anything that leaks will get lost, or will leave you with a very pinched second shot into the heavily-treed green. As I played the course, it seemed like somebody was always looking through the creekside brush for a disc that didn't make the green. Walking off that hole with a safe and simple par made me feel like a genius
Cons:
- There are some really good holes here, but the middle third of the course is pretty dull, with a stretch of wide open park style holes.
- The hole-to-hole layout isn't always intuitive, and there's some extra walking to cross the creek. These are pretty minor complaints - but there is one spot of potential danger: getting to the 11th green, the only way across the creek is to walk on the very narrow shoulder of a busy road
Other Thoughts:
~ The wide open nature of some holes might give the impression that it's a good place for beginners, but there's so much trouble on the other holes that I'd think twice before bringing anyone who has a tendency to spray their shots
~ This course is very manageable for an intermediate player. A few of the pars 3's are on the longish side for the distance-challenged, but a safe and well-placed tee shot will almost always result in an achievable up-and-down for par
~ Based on pictures I've seen on various sites, the challenges presented by this course vary with the seasons. When I played in June, the foliage around the creek was thick. The windows for throwing on #1, #12, #13 were pretty small, compared to pictures I see from early Spring and Winter
~ This course is open - but it will jump up and bite you at the edges. And that goes back to the design that uses this property so well. I guess you could design a course here with a more intuitive layout - but the holes wouldn't be as good, or as inviting for repeat plays. I think the designer did what makes the most sense: make the best holes possible, even if that means some extra walking.
RECOMMENDED COMBINATIONS:
Pay a small donation and warm up at the wooded, short Mt. Lebanon Camp Meeting course.Then put together a triangle with Jackson Recreational, South Hills and Lenni Lenape for an excellent day of varied disc golf.