• Discover new ways to elevate your game with the updated DGCourseReview app!
    It's entirely free and enhanced with features shaped by user feedback to ensure your best experience on the course. (App Store or Google Play)

In Memory: The Best Extinct Courses

I played Coyote in KY and predicted it to become a top 10 in my review, it's sad I'll never be able to return.

I was planning a trip through that area when Coyote Trace shut down. I had to go with plan B, Holler in the Hills, which was amazing and sadly extinct a month after I played it. Holler is by far the best course I've played that is now extinct. The property it was on is probably the best disc golf terrain that I've come across.


Hole 17 basket to tee. You can't tell in the pic, but there is a 30' deep valley between the tee and basket.

df9bcfda.jpg


Examples of some of the cool rock formations used in the course. The pics really don't do them any justice.

84beb575.jpg


9bd505de.jpg
 
Another is C.Bickham Dickson Park in Shreveport, La. It wasn't the best course in the world, but it was fun to play (lots of ace runs) and the park used to be one of the most beautiful places to go. Floods have decimated it for all but hiking and fishing now.
 
I second those who mentioned Circle-R. Haven't been to Selah so I can't compare, but I loved every inch of that place. Fabulous.
 
Another is C.Bickham Dickson Park in Shreveport, La. It wasn't the best course in the world, but it was fun to play (lots of ace runs) and the park used to be one of the most beautiful places to go. Floods have decimated it for all but hiking and fishing now.

C Bickham was the 1st new disc golf course for Shreveport in... pretty much ever. Ford, Highland and Clyde Fant were all existing frisbee golf courses that were later converted to Disc Golf. The city works has just ignored it even though the water level went down.:mad:
 
It is interesting that a few courses have hosted a World Championship and are extinct, yet they've not sniffed a mention on this thread.

Well, perhaps a mention:

Gran Canyon, Brooksville, FL
Still Waters Farm, Govan, SC

Are two of my Top-5 all-time. Until recently I considered the Canyon the best course I'd ever played.

Stonhenge, Nashville, TN is pretty high on my list, as well

Met a guy Sunday who had played Laurel Springs, which I just missed playing and is now about 15 years extinct.

Stonehenge was part of 2001 Am Worlds.
 
It is interesting that a few courses have hosted a World Championship and are extinct, yet they've not sniffed a mention on this thread.
No one's prohibiting you from mentioning them. Please share.
 
Boylan Family Farm. Laurel Springs, N.C.

One of my all time favorites and I haven't played it
since the 90's.
 
My anxiety level is kind of off the chart, wondering if Sugaree will reopen in May. I'm afraid to ask. It's like that first time falling in love with a girl, everything in the world is sunny and the birds are singing, and then she tells you she's moving somewhere so far away, that you'll never see her again. You can feel your heart skip a few beats. Your stomach sinks, you look for somewhere to sit down. That's how I feel about the special courses in my life.
 
My anxiety level is kind of off the chart, wondering if Sugaree will reopen in May. I'm afraid to ask. It's like that first time falling in love with a girl, everything in the world is sunny and the birds are singing, and then she tells you she's moving somewhere so far away, that you'll never see her again. You can feel your heart skip a few beats. Your stomach sinks, you look for somewhere to sit down. That's how I feel about the special courses in my life.

I think I remember reading that Mando doesn't want to have Sugaree listed any longer, but it's not closing. Would love to be able to play that one someday.
 
I think I remember reading that Mando doesn't want to have Sugaree listed any longer, but it's not closing. Would love to be able to play that one someday.

It's everything you've heard it is! Unique. Beautiful. Extreme. Tough. Rewarding. Fun. The topography there is just about the most otherworldly I have ever seen, as someone that has not strayed far from The NC Piedmont. We need unique courses, like this, lest our heart and soul feel lost, and empty.
 
I think in terms of uniqueness, Crystal City has to win this debate, right?...
As you said, "in terms of uniqueness," Crystal City at least has to be in the conversation. It wasn't necessarily great DG, but it was unlike any other course I've played. The ultimate glow round with walls and ceilings, atmosphere completely unlike anything else.

Often misstated as being in a cave, it was underground, but in a former silica mine, and completely man-made... so no geologic formations like stalactites or stalagmites. It was a maze of intersecting tunnels with fairways of extremely fine sand that found it's way into everything... found it's way into compartments in my bag that were zipped shut the entire time.
 
My anxiety level is kind of off the chart, wondering if Sugaree will reopen in May. I'm afraid to ask. It's like that first time falling in love with a girl, everything in the world is sunny and the birds are singing, and then she tells you she's moving somewhere so far away, that you'll never see her again. You can feel your heart skip a few beats. Your stomach sinks, you look for somewhere to sit down. That's how I feel about the special courses in my life.

I think I remember reading that Mando doesn't want to have Sugaree listed any longer, but it's not closing. Would love to be able to play that one someday.
He told me last week it's closed for good, unless he gets new knees which is unlikely. :(
 
Gran Canyon, Brooksville, FL
Still Waters Farm, Govan, SC

Are two of my Top-5 all-time. Until recently I considered the Canyon the best course I'd ever played.

Stonhenge, Nashville, TN is pretty high on my list, as well

Met a guy Sunday who had played Laurel Springs, which I just missed playing and is now about 15 years extinct.

Well, things have changed a bit in the 5 1/2 years since I posted that. The Canyon has gone from extinct to virtually-extinct, mystically appearing as a temp course once a year, not in its original configuration but still awful good. In the meantime, Hampton Park, the annual temp course in Charleston, SC that was also one of my all-time favorites, is only a memory now.

Now, Sugaree?

What hasn't changed is my advice to support and love your local private courses. You don't know how long they'll be with you. And don't take your favorite public courses for granted, either---you never know when the local government or community will decide they have a better use for the land, so try not to give them extra reasons to consider alternatives to the disc golf course.
 

Latest posts

Top