[Vs.] Wizard, the Greatest Putter Ever vs. the judge

[Streets]

Let's settle this.

 

[shroom]

Hands down no contest. Wizard wins

 

[dysmike]

Wizard, you can lay into it.. or not... and it pretty much just does what it's told.

 

[Brodysseus]

I enjoy how biased, yet accurate, the title is.

Wizard.

 

[Halcón]

MVP Ion is the best putter ever.

Oh sorry, I said I would give up trolling Streets threads for 2015.

 

[dysmike]

MVP Ion is the best putter ever.

Oh sorry, I said I would give up trolling Streets threads for 2015.

I tried it, went back to Wizards. The Ion flew fine, felt horrid. so... Meh. Besides, it's pretty much a Wizard knock-off

 

[Vorpaljesus]

If only a wizard felt like a judge. Or a judge flew like a wizard

 

[Halcón]

If I wasn't putting with Ions, it would be Wizards. It's a heck of a disc. Just not as good as its upgrade.

FWIW, this whole Judge thing seems to be gaining steam. Do Feldberg and Ricky throw them?

 

[dysmike]

If only a wizard felt like a judge. Or a judge flew like a wizard

The Judge does feel good.. it lasted a whopping 2 rounds in my bag though before I gave it to a newbie.

 

[bobmcnelly]

Is the Judge less stable?

 

[Stardoggy]

The Judge is nothing more than a lame Wizard wannabe.

 

[Sooner34]

If I wasn't putting with Ions, it would be Wizards. It's a heck of a disc. Just not as good as its upgrade.

FWIW, this whole Judge thing seems to be gaining steam. Do Feldberg and Ricky throw them?

Feldberg uses one for outside the circle putts. Wysocki seems to use his Dagger from everywhere as opposed to Feldy who only uses them from inside the circle. Wysocki could always change it up this early though.

 

[dysmike]

Is the Judge less stable?

Yes. More turn before it fades... then not as much fade.

 

[Scared_Discless]

Let's settle this.

 

[tbird888]

Why are the results so lopsided? If you look at onemile's bracket, the Judge is monumentally better than the Aviar.

 

[Streets]

MVP Ion is the best putter ever.

Oh sorry, I said I would give up trolling Streets threads for 2015.

Touche, good sir. Touche.

 

[World Eater]

Try the shield. feels like a judge, comes in BT soft and is good for short putts and drives. I don't think it carries like a wizard, but its faf, it's not going to if it's flat like a judge.

The judge is different than a wizard. Its a strange comparison. Imo the Anode is the best all-around putter I've thrown.

I putt with judges and swans and drive with shields.

Edit : trilogy fed people to the polls. dgcr did too, but our votes were drowned by Facebook. I don't know why you need your bag validated by online polls anyway. If the judge won this poll would you have switched???

 

[riltim]

Over the past 4 years I've switched away from the wizard for:
* Ion
* Anode
* Challenger
* Clozer
* Mercy
* Judge

I've come back to the wizard every time. It really is the greatest putter of all time.

 

[whentherainscome]

I've stopped using the Wizard as a driver/approach disc, but I've still got them for 60' and in. The Judge does feel good, I got one as a CFR/Player Pack disc. If I wasn't putting with Wizards ..I'd be using the Challenger!

 

[@iDiscGolf]

Why are the results so lopsided? If you look at onemile's bracket, the Judge is monumentally better than the Aviar.

I think people like beaded putters better now. Wizard, judge, ion etc.

How about we all agree that beaded putters are better and settle it. Why does everyone get so offended when "their" putter isn't the top ranked?