Hlasianguy06
Eagle Member
Their onsite review said they smelled like cat piss, both him and a friend purchased a pair and had the same problem.:gross:
-
Discover new ways to elevate your game with the updated DGCourseReview app!
It's entirely free and enhanced with features shaped by user feedback to ensure your best experience on the course. (App Store or Google Play)
DG shoe addicts, share your expertise!
- Thread starter discdoh
- Start date
Their onsite review said they smelled like cat piss, both him and a friend purchased a pair and had the same problem.:gross:
ckcarves
Newbie
Ordered these for $55 shipped
And these for $65
Sierra had a 35% code with free shipping.
I wouldn't waste a nickel on Salomons but I'm interested in this code you speak of.
Gennataos
Eagle Member
When I read stories like these, I feel they're full of as much hyperbole and half-truths as they are fact and have more to do with the footwork of an individual than the construction of a shoe.
I do agree that the waterproofing won't hold up to a full year of use. But a hole forming after a "couple" toe drags? The traction on a Vibram sole "completely" wore off? No traction on a wet teepad?
jrmac0
Bogey Member
- Joined
- Feb 1, 2014
- Messages
- 65
Shoe will be available this summer.
dsb1829
Birdie Member
Re NF Hedgehog
Great shoe, very comfy, good waterproofing...
But if you are a toe dragger the soft vibram will grate off quickly. I only got about 4mo out of them b4 they wore to the goretex. I only throw forehand ~20% of the time. Adjust mileage accordingly if you throw/drag more often.
Great shoe, very comfy, good waterproofing...
But if you are a toe dragger the soft vibram will grate off quickly. I only got about 4mo out of them b4 they wore to the goretex. I only throw forehand ~20% of the time. Adjust mileage accordingly if you throw/drag more often.
You guy are looking in the wrong genre. I looked across the pond at our ball golfing brotheren and decided to give a pair of their shoes a try. I picked up some adidas crossflex 2 spikeless golf shoes and they are awesome. They are sturdy, waterproof, have tons of traction, and are holding up awesome. To top all of that off you can find them on eBay for under $50 to your door!
http://www.budgetgolf.com/Adidas-Cr...&cagpspn=pla&gclid=CJvD2_3J7bwCFeJF7Aod7lcAcg
http://www.budgetgolf.com/Adidas-Cr...&cagpspn=pla&gclid=CJvD2_3J7bwCFeJF7Aod7lcAcg
From a fellow vff nut, thanks for the heads up. Been wanting to try spyridons but budget is tight right now. Was going to just get a pair of new balance for the upcoming season because of price (ksos are about done after multiple seasons). Just ordered some spyridons for what I had set aside for new balances. Hard not to buy a second pair of vffs at those prices.
Hlasianguy06
Eagle Member
If you have fat toes the mesh will rip after a couple weekends at the course. Just saying it will happen, went through two pairs of spyridons, second is still usable but only on lush courses. Sticks and dirt is annoying between the toes. Rock block plate is awesome though.
Hlasianguy06
Eagle Member
Don't know why I never thought of that. Usually I have a problem with busting seems. I'm trying to find a leather/nubuck one piece design in the forefoot to heel shank with a Vibram sole. My shoes with Vibram soles broke at the fabric(even nu Buck from abrasions and pressure against the hard sole) and never got to wear away the Vibram, there was toe pivot wear but nothing significant. On the contrary my non Vibram sole shoes (keens) wore very quickly at the soles but the upper lasted slightly longer than say my vasques. Gonna give these oboz a run this weekend but they do feel a bit narrow, wearing them around the house now to stretch em out a bit.
Subicon
Par Member
Last spring, I played a tourney with some rough terrain and my old shoes just didn't have the traction I needed, so I decided to spring for some nice trail shoes. I had great experience with my Asolo boots over the years, so I decided to try out their shoes.
I bought a pair of Asolo Mantra. Pros - Comfortable, durable (Vibram soles), and mildly water resistant. Cons - They run narrow. I've never had to buy any shoes in a wider than normal size before, but I would have been more comfortable if I had.
They didn't bother me too much, but on long discing days, it would really start to hurt my pinky toe on my right foot. It has an odd curve to the outside of the shoes which just didn't fit my foot well. To counteract that, I kept the laces near the toes looser than the top. Other than that issue, the shoes performed great. I've had them about nine months and they've been very solid with grip and durability. There are a few small chunks missing from the soles now, but I haven't had any issues with that so far.
I recently purchased some Keen Marshal WP. Pros - They are fairly comfortable (support and cushion), have good traction, and lightweight. Cons - Very hot. My feet were cooking even when the temps were <50F. Only worn them for a few rounds and they're already showing signs of wear. I honestly don't think they'll last me for even six months. Also, the toes of the shoes are rounded off, not giving much room for your big and middle toes.
I wear size 12 in everything, but I think I should have gone with a 12. I walked around in them a good bit in the store and they felt great. But, after only a few rounds, they are causing some issues with toes. On my right foot, I think the shoe was pushing on my big toenail and now it is partially black. I might lose the nail. Needless to say, I'm not too happy.
I am going out and seeing if I can find something better suited today.
I bought a pair of Asolo Mantra. Pros - Comfortable, durable (Vibram soles), and mildly water resistant. Cons - They run narrow. I've never had to buy any shoes in a wider than normal size before, but I would have been more comfortable if I had.
They didn't bother me too much, but on long discing days, it would really start to hurt my pinky toe on my right foot. It has an odd curve to the outside of the shoes which just didn't fit my foot well. To counteract that, I kept the laces near the toes looser than the top. Other than that issue, the shoes performed great. I've had them about nine months and they've been very solid with grip and durability. There are a few small chunks missing from the soles now, but I haven't had any issues with that so far.
I recently purchased some Keen Marshal WP. Pros - They are fairly comfortable (support and cushion), have good traction, and lightweight. Cons - Very hot. My feet were cooking even when the temps were <50F. Only worn them for a few rounds and they're already showing signs of wear. I honestly don't think they'll last me for even six months. Also, the toes of the shoes are rounded off, not giving much room for your big and middle toes.
I wear size 12 in everything, but I think I should have gone with a 12. I walked around in them a good bit in the store and they felt great. But, after only a few rounds, they are causing some issues with toes. On my right foot, I think the shoe was pushing on my big toenail and now it is partially black. I might lose the nail. Needless to say, I'm not too happy.
I am going out and seeing if I can find something better suited today.
Last edited:
McFer
* Innova: Choice of Champions *
- Joined
- Apr 5, 2012
- Messages
- 681
After tearing through a pair of Moab GTX's in 6 months, and then a pair of Salomon XA Pro 3D Ultra 2 GTX's in about 4 months, I kind of gave up and bought the cheapest shoes I could find with a Vibram sole and some form of waterproofing. I ended up getting these:
http://www.6pm.com/the-north-face-storm-wp-tnf-black-dark-shadow-grey
Nothing to really complain about for $62. Not nearly as comfortable as the Salomons, and not nearly as all around awesome as the Merrells. But I won't feel quite so bad if I'm shoe shopping again in 3 months.
http://www.6pm.com/the-north-face-storm-wp-tnf-black-dark-shadow-grey
Nothing to really complain about for $62. Not nearly as comfortable as the Salomons, and not nearly as all around awesome as the Merrells. But I won't feel quite so bad if I'm shoe shopping again in 3 months.
http://www.zappos.com/the-north-face-hedgehog-guide-gtx-biking-red-malbec-red
anyone try these hedgehogs? I think they are the newer versions.
wondering how durable they are
anyone try these hedgehogs? I think they are the newer versions.
wondering how durable they are
I'm constantly on the search for the next best dg shoe, and I think I've found it, Merrell Proterra's. I've owned the majority of the top shoes on the market (Merrell, New Balance, Saloman, Keen) and the Proterra's are spectacular. Light, nimble, but rugged where it needs to be, waterproof/Gore-Tex, reasonably priced, couldn't be happier.
https://www.merrell.com/US/en-US/Product.mvc.aspx/30885M/74566/Mens/Proterra-Sport
https://www.merrell.com/US/en-US/Product.mvc.aspx/30885M/74566/Mens/Proterra-Sport
Raging Tide
Bogey Member
I like my proterra sports but they are not waterproof. The link you provided clearly stated that. I think these are good shoes, but keep an eye out eye for deals as I paid $50 new for mine.
Oops, I posted the wrong link, here is the Gore-Tex waterproof model....
http://www.merrell.com/US/en-US/Pro...588/Mens/Proterra-Sport-GORE-TEX?dimensions=0
For me, protection from dewy morning grass is the extent of my need for waterproof shoes, I don't venture into any water. These Proterra's do a perfect job unlike some of my other dg shoes.
Declarkus
Double Eagle Member
First of all, Discdoh gave great feedback as the theadfather. Then it started to turn into what people bought. I'd love to hear some new shoe reviews. Pros and Cons, comfort and durability. Also, a specific model is much more helpful than "Merrells."
My Merrell Road Gloves (written on the size tag) are not ideal for DG. Admittedly, they were cheap, not built for off road use, and I'm tired of trying to make them work. I'd really like to hear descriptive reviews like Discdoh. That's the kind of useful information anyone looking to buy DG-friendly shoes wants to have. Thx!
I've noticed on this and other shoe threads how people love to talk price, and say "not bad for the money." Cheap should scare you. Materials and craftsmanship are sacrificed for a lower price. If I were forced to make shoes in jail, I doubt I'd have enough incentive to make it well. I'll save you the politics, but things are outsourced because of consumers' obsession with the price tag. The most expensive option isn't always the best one, but the best option is rarely the cheapest. Are they great or just okay and cheap? Let others determine value for themselves.
I would love more votes for their favorite DG shoes. Here's a list of shoes that folks have mentioned. Please provide feedback on them or any others you're enjoying.
Adidas Crossflex 2 (golf shoes), Terrex Fast X, Terrex Swift R GTX
Cushe Baja
Garmont Zenith
Keen Delaveaga, Marshall, Siskiyou, Turani CNX, Zion
La Sportiva FC Eco 2.0 GTX
Lowa Renegade
Merrell Moab
New Balance Minimus, 411, 911, 989, 1521
North Face Hedgehog GTX 3
Oboz Arete, Firebrand, Sawtooth, Dark Shadow, Yellowstone
Salewa Alpine, Firetail?
Saucony Xodus 4.0 GTX
Vasque Juxt
Vivobarefoot "trail shoe", "hiker"
That's just from 2 threads. There's soo many. Oboz, Keen and North Face kept coming up. I'm intrigued by Salewa, La Sportiva, and Cushe.
I'm also curious about experiences with specialty shoes, like spikeless golf shoes and shot putting/discus shoes.
I want this thread to help EVERYONE interested in DG shoes, so please don't withhold.
My Merrell Road Gloves (written on the size tag) are not ideal for DG. Admittedly, they were cheap, not built for off road use, and I'm tired of trying to make them work. I'd really like to hear descriptive reviews like Discdoh. That's the kind of useful information anyone looking to buy DG-friendly shoes wants to have. Thx!
I've noticed on this and other shoe threads how people love to talk price, and say "not bad for the money." Cheap should scare you. Materials and craftsmanship are sacrificed for a lower price. If I were forced to make shoes in jail, I doubt I'd have enough incentive to make it well. I'll save you the politics, but things are outsourced because of consumers' obsession with the price tag. The most expensive option isn't always the best one, but the best option is rarely the cheapest. Are they great or just okay and cheap? Let others determine value for themselves.
I would love more votes for their favorite DG shoes. Here's a list of shoes that folks have mentioned. Please provide feedback on them or any others you're enjoying.
Adidas Crossflex 2 (golf shoes), Terrex Fast X, Terrex Swift R GTX
Cushe Baja
Garmont Zenith
Keen Delaveaga, Marshall, Siskiyou, Turani CNX, Zion
La Sportiva FC Eco 2.0 GTX
Lowa Renegade
Merrell Moab
New Balance Minimus, 411, 911, 989, 1521
North Face Hedgehog GTX 3
Oboz Arete, Firebrand, Sawtooth, Dark Shadow, Yellowstone
Salewa Alpine, Firetail?
Saucony Xodus 4.0 GTX
Vasque Juxt
Vivobarefoot "trail shoe", "hiker"
That's just from 2 threads. There's soo many. Oboz, Keen and North Face kept coming up. I'm intrigued by Salewa, La Sportiva, and Cushe.
I'm also curious about experiences with specialty shoes, like spikeless golf shoes and shot putting/discus shoes.
I want this thread to help EVERYONE interested in DG shoes, so please don't withhold.
Declarkus
Double Eagle Member
Bump for shoe reviews...
I like the Keen Targhee 2 Mid Boots. They are very waterproof and are all around tanks for my feet. When I get out on the course, I like being able to stomp around without worrying about a puddle or mud. These boots create that comfort level for me so I don't have to tip toe around. They will probably get really hot this summer, but I will just cycle a new pair of socks after every round. If I get in a rhythm of buying a new pair once a year, thats $120 I don't mind spending. My only concern is that I throw a lot of FH and end up tearing through the toes of a lot of shoes. The toes on these seem really tough so time will tell.
After tearing through a pair of Moab GTX's in 6 months, and then a pair of Salomon XA Pro 3D Ultra 2 GTX's in about 4 months, I kind of gave up and bought the cheapest shoes I could find with a Vibram sole and some form of waterproofing. I ended up getting these:
http://www.6pm.com/the-north-face-storm-wp-tnf-black-dark-shadow-grey
Nothing to really complain about for $62. Not nearly as comfortable as the Salomons, and not nearly as all around awesome as the Merrells. But I won't feel quite so bad if I'm shoe shopping again in 3 months.
I ordered these 1/2 size up and they still crushed my forefoot. Way too narrow. Saw them priced at $65 on Zappos. Had to send them back.
