For me a Wizard on the stiffer side. Though unless the hole is very short (165ft or less) I feel more comfortable throwing a roc.
Discover new ways to elevate your game with the updated DGCourseReview app!
It's entirely free and enhanced with features shaped by user feedback to ensure your best experience on the course. (App Store or Google Play)
You know your game better than anyone else but this seems like an overstatement. I've been driving and approaching with the same two stiff KC Pro Aviars on heavily wooded MN courses for 2 and half years now. One is finally getting flippy and the other is still overstable on a 275' shot. To each his own but I wouldn't make such a harsh judgement of base plastic putters based on one Soft Challenger. A huge majority of pros and world champs use base plastic putters for a lot of shots.
If you don't like the feel of base or midgrade plastics then the FLX Challenger can work. It's still got less glide than a D Challenger but they fly better than Cryztal and break in a little faster.
I agree it depends on how you throw and all that stuff, but the mention of MN courses had me throw this out for consideration. I had a KC Roc, not a putter but I am commenting about the plastic, that was chewed up very quickly at Plymouth Creek. Courses like Plymouth, Clearwater, Lakewood, and Acorn which are more hard dirt than grass can do quite a number on baseline plastics if you are not lucky (which seems to be the key in this discussion).
Last fall through this winter my Mach Lite basket absolutely trashed an X Soft Focus. This same basket has also taken huge chunks out of a Soft Wizard and a few DX Rhynos.
I have had the best luck with Vibram putters and Ions for durability, but I also have a couple of SSS Voodoos that have held up nicely.
However, when it comes to driving, I personally find it easier to take a neutral mid like a Buzzz SS or a Fuse and drive with those with some power taken off. They sit in my hand better, giving me cleaner releases, but this is just me.
HPP Wizard then. Or try the Prodiscus Jokeri.
Great, now I feel bad for forgetting to include the Ridge...I know that a lot of guys give Vibram putters grief, but I like them.
I too am looking for a premium plastic putter to drive with. I loved my pro/rpro rhynos, but my local course is full of rocks, good or bad drive you're going to hit some rocks when you land. It's really a matter of luck on how much damage will be done by them. I had a stiffer rpro rhyno that I beat into a soft floppy disc with no fade in about 4 months with constant driving and approaches. Granted, I love the way it seasoned in, but it flies nothing like a rhyno anymore. I recently switched out to Wizards and I'm loving them, although they're not as overstable as I imagined, just stable which is taking a little getting used to. I'm still not sure if I like them for driving, but they do fly forever. I've got a champ rhyno on it's way from prerube, hopefully that'll solve the problem, because I love driving rhynos. Still thinking about a HPP Voodoo though, liking the S Voodoo I have now a little more than the wiz for driving.
I too am looking for a premium plastic putter to drive with. I loved my pro/rpro rhynos, but my local course is full of rocks, good or bad drive you're going to hit some rocks when you land. It's really a matter of luck on how much damage will be done by them. I had a stiffer rpro rhyno that I beat into a soft floppy disc with no fade in about 4 months with constant driving and approaches. Granted, I love the way it seasoned in, but it flies nothing like a rhyno anymore. I recently switched out to Wizards and I'm loving them, although they're not as overstable as I imagined, just stable which is taking a little getting used to. I'm still not sure if I like them for driving, but they do fly forever. I've got a champ rhyno on it's way from prerube, hopefully that'll solve the problem, because I love driving rhynos. Still thinking about a HPP Voodoo though, liking the S Voodoo I have now a little more than the wiz for driving.