I feel a lot of sympathy for Paul and suspect that the theft may have cost him this tourney (although he'll probably disagree and he still took it to a playoff). I'm more than a little surprised that he did not carry a backup bag, or at least backup discs.
I haven't played tourneys for a while, but back then I always carried a backup for every disc. Plus I would carry windy day discs. Surprised he didn't do this. Perhaps the travelling vehicle was full. Obviously, he didn't think he'd need it.
I keep reading things like the bolded and I don't understand why anyone is under the impression that McBeth didn't have back-ups with him. Of course he did. Every single disc he threw on Friday and Saturday were discs he had with him and most likely were all disc he had thrown a few times each so they weren't brand new. He didn't need to borrow discs from other players or buy them in a store. Like any other prepared player, he had them. The only thing he reportedly borrowed was his girlfriend's Grip bag to carry them all in because apparently but not necessarily surprisingly, he only has one Grip bag with him on the road.
How many of us carry two identical bags with us to every tournament? Back up discs? Of course. A second bag? If we have one, it's probably not the same bag we use regularly...it's probably an old bag or a smaller bag for those quick putter-only type rounds. But if we've got boxes of discs in the trunk/truck/5th wheel, maybe there's no real need for an extra bag too. We all anticipate the chances of losing a disc or two to water or an errant throw into the scrub, but who anticipates an entire bag up and disappearing?
Given how close he came to winning, maybe we can debate whether having his tried and trusted discs for the last two rounds might have saved him a stroke and the win. But by and large, he's a player good enough to play with his back-ups and beat pretty much anybody. The bag getting stolen was a distraction, but probably not enough to blame for not winning the tournament. The feeling of violation of having something taken from him, whether it's a golf bag or his wallet or his ipod or whatever, is probably bothering him more in an off-the-course way than it did on the course.