Cat just beat Paige, Liz, and Shiela this weekend at the VPO.
Contrast that with Paige and Val. Paige had huge wins at the KC Wide Open, Memorial, Masters Cup, Stockholm Open, and Worlds. Val took down the European Open, Beaver State Fling, Brent Hambrick, PDGA Championship, and USDGC. All of those events had large, competitive fields, usually including Catrina!
Cat would have taken 2nd at Nats if sshe had not taken a 22 on an island hole the first round. I don't know if she was not aware that she could lay up and cancel the retee, or if she really tin cupped it, but I think it's significant that she would have beaten Paige, and Liz, and everyone except Val if not for that one mistake.
And how many of those players debuted with an 850 rating, and progressed to top ten in the first year?
Cat is a solid player, and will probably get better since she tours and plays more events than any other woman out there. The other top touring women pros are in no danger of being dominated yet, though.
If she stays with it, she could win World's next year. And all she has to do to move into the top 4 is let some old rounds drop off. I don't think it will be long now. I wouldbn't be surprised if you change your mind next year.