I was referring to a 600' hole at my course -- you said you birdied a 400' hole. Are you capable of throwing 600'? Even on a 450' drive, you will still be 150' out. Or, I can do one 350' drive and a 200'+ upshot and be in place for an easy par. Either way, you get there in 3. That was my original point. Yes, on 450' holes, your arm will definitely be better and will put you in place for the bird. Likewise, on short holes that require accuracy, my control and matching discs will net me an easy bird or maybe better. Also, with a big arm comes the possibility of overshooting a hole -- which at my course means O.B. on pretty much every hole.
Once again, my original point was that on most holes, I prefer control over max D. I've played with guys who can get more D than me, but can't do a mid-range shot to save their life. Whereas my drive may go 100' less, my solid mid skills get me to the hole and they have to take a second shot anyway -- I took the "long" route but end up with the same score.
Garret