Matthews, NC

The Scrapyard

3.715(based on 45 reviews)
Filter course reviews

Filter reviews

Filter reviews

The Scrapyard reviews

Filter
13 0
Shadrach3
Gold level trusted reviewer
Experience: 5.6 years 319 played 310 reviews
3.00 star(s)

Pine and Pond 2+ years

Reviewed: Played on:Jan 25, 2022 Played the course:once

Pros:

A course that is rightfully most famous for its water carries.

-Amenities: Surprisingly enough for a Charlotte course, excellent. Midsize concrete tees, great signs with most, DISCathcers. Next tee cues. Some distance to the pin markers.

-Maintenance: Really good. The fairways are wide and defined through the pine forest, and though the rough is punishing, it is easily navigable. The pond is dredged regularly for discs.

-Environment: Decently secluded forest. The pond in the middle is iconic and pleasant.

-Water Carries: Two nice water carries. The first brings in a low ceiling and lots of trees behind the green, while the second has water on the right and a steep slope away from the basket on the left.

-Shot Shaping/Gameplay: A nice curation, but not particularly remarkable. Holes are all in the woods, and the most common shape is a simple dogleg par-3. Two par-4s and a par-5 are on the short end but add a nice bit of variety. Missing the fairway may well leave you at the mercy of tree kicks, which can easily force bogeys. Scrapyard has a pleasant collection of woods shots, but to my eye it's not the place with a lot of charm or uniqueness.

-Multi-Tees: Some holes have multiple tees, including the water carries.

Cons:

-Blind Holes: Quite a lot of holes are blind. This is a bit of a nuisance for players who haven't memorized the course.

-Questionable Shapes: Here and there, the fairway shapes are questionable, with curves to tight or wiggles too frequent. That said, I think all the fairways are possible to throw, just potentially very awkward.

-Fun Factor: Scrapyard lacks the kind of creative terrain or unique scenery to set it apart from a good many other solid woods courses. Don't get me wrong, it's fun to play here, but it's not the kind of course that will leave a strong impression on a bagger like me.

Other Thoughts:

I've had the Scrapyard in my mind for quite a while due to hole (8)'s strong presence on disc golf social media. Upon playing, I consider it a Good course that appears to provide a nice home for a good many local golfers. Its plethora of woods doglegs is unobjectionable. It's well suited for a particular vibe, so decide for yourself if it's worth a trip!
Was this review helpful? Yes No
3 6
Klingmeyer
Experience: 7.8 years 23 played 18 reviews
3.00 star(s)

Hiking/Disc Golf 2+ years drive by

Reviewed: Played on:Jun 24, 2017 Played the course:once

Pros:

Concrete tee pads, decent baskets, slight elevation changes, clear fairways, not much chance of losing a disc except the water holes.

Cons:

Signage to next tee is there but could use an upgrade, long walks between some tee pads, water collects after heavy rain, quite a few roots.

Other Thoughts:

This course was wet after the recent rain, but playable. The course seems to play longer on some holes than expected,neither good or bad. I didn't throw from the long tees on the water holes. I could probably make the distance, but wasn't willing to take the chance of an errant throw or wind. Losing $15.00+ isn't worth it to me. An interesting course with good basket placement requiring all your throws. It does feel like a hike through the woods with disc golf included.
Was this review helpful? Yes No
10 3
Bennybennybenny
Diamond level trusted reviewer
Experience: 13.2 years 306 played 288 reviews
3.00 star(s)

The Scrap (Where I played like crap) 2+ years

Reviewed: Played on:Jun 22, 2014 Played the course:once

Pros:

-I never made time to play this course and in the CAC, let's just say I paid for it. The course actually gave me a wedgie and I wore my underwear over my head at Dry Creek after my round here. This is a good course in a good park. If the baseball fields are empty, you can warm up in the fields. This course is all wooded so you must hit your line or you will shoot a +12 like I did.
-Well defined fairways on this course. Hole 15 is super narrow but the short distance makes up for it. Some can be hard to hit because the fairways are very diverse. You don't know what you will get but they are all fair.
-There is a practice basket on your way to hole 1 beside the parking lot in the woods. Walk up a little further and you will find hole 1. There are also amenities. Trash bags on almost every hole if not all, there are bathrooms beside hole 1 and benches on almost every hole.
-This isn't hard to navigate. Sure, there are a few fairly long transitions but there are next tee signs. Just follow the wider paths. For instance, the transition from 6 to 7 could be considered "difficult." So go down the WIDER path after hole 6.
-I love both of the water holes. My favorite hole was #8 but I think #9 is easily the signature hole. #8 from the short is a fun ace run with a nice water carry and from the long tee, it has that Buckhorn feeling to it. It's 300 feet from the long so you will need a good 280+ shot over the pond. #9 is a harder hole. You only play over the water from the long tee. It's a fun hyzer shot over the pond. It definitely requires a long driver throw from the long tee and there is a steep drop off near 20' down left of the basket. The short tee is just a righty flick in the woods.
-Good length variety on this course. There are a few holes <200' and there is one right at 500'. #7 is the longest hole at 500', it's the hole that requires the most accuracy. It's long and very tough.
-There is some elevation out here. Not very much but some. #4 is the hardest hole in my book. The drive is quite a bit uphill so the hole plays longer than 432' and the fairway does turn left but you still don't want to throw a driver. The woods are more difficult on this hole.

Cons:

-Most of the holes are just good at the best. Only #8 and #9 were the really fun holes out here. I'm not saying those were the only two I liked but in 20 years from now, if someone were to ask me "Remember Idlewild Park?" I'd probably just say "Oh yeah, the Scrapyard."
-The water can get up pretty high. If you throw a disc in the water, you will really want to pay attention to wear it landed because if it landed more than 10 feet from the fairway, you won't see it. You will have to FEEL it. Don't get confused with a rock.
-Fairways are fair but that doesn't mean it would hurt to chop a few down. #12 needs a couple chopped down because the fairway is very odd. It would be good if a couple were chopped down too on #18.
-It's just too hard on rollers. Even some of the trees will cause rollers. The drop offs can be very unforgiving.
-Few filler holes here. #9 short is definitely disappointing. It's just a short ace run in the woods. If you play the shorts. I recommend you just play the long tee on this hole.
-The tee pads could be longer and a few are raised. I really don't like raised tee pads. Especially #10's. If you have a huge run up like I do, you will not be satisfied.

Other Thoughts:

-This is a good course in South Charlotte. Worth the play if you live around Charlotte. If you are just visiting, I recommend you play something else because there are so many more courses in Charlotte that have lots of variety. You do get to play holes 8 and 9 though but they are the only stand outs here and they are both of the water holes. I think you will leave happy here if you play Idlewild but you may be disappointed if you really want variety. If that is what you want, play Dry Creek, or Angry Beaver. They got so much more variety than Idlewild. However, I do not recall any holes here that I disliked. None of them are actually bad like there are at most courses.
-I do wish I played this course sooner than I did, I just never made the time to play it. Definitely find time to play here if you live around Charlotte, you might really love it. I liked it but wanted a little more.
Was this review helpful? Yes No
8 0
Hector Chain
Diamond level trusted reviewer
Experience: 15.9 years 222 played 191 reviews
3.00 star(s)

2+ years

Reviewed: Played on:Dec 19, 2013 Played the course:once

Pros:

Scrapyard is a succession of wooded holes of varying lengths and tightness. The longer par 4s are challenging and remind you to stick carefully to the fairway, much like Nevin or the wooded holes at Hornet's Nest. The shorter holes are tough birdies and force you to hit a particular line, but pars are not hard to come by if your placement is good.
There are two water carries, which is pretty rare in these parts. Hole 8 is not a difficult throw across, and even a solid Rec player with decent accuracy should be able to make it across. Hole 9 is a longer carry to the basket perched on a sort of earthen dam about 10 feet from the shore. It is a fun, longer ace run for RHBH players, although a birdie is pretty tough (and maybe unlikely) due to the steep slope to the left of the basket. Both water holes have shorter tee pads that avoid the water carries, if you are nervous.
I liked some of the longer holes that opened up into lightly wooded fairways, the kind that offer you multiple lines of varying difficulty. These are the ones that are fun to replay.
Tee pads are concrete. I think I looked at the map once or twice, but navigation was generally fine.

Cons:

The rough here was pretty bad. On one hole my turnover shot didn't turn over and just went straight into the rough, maybe 20 feet. I took a 6 on that hole because it took three shots to get out of the rough. It was a drive that deserved to be punished, but not with three strokes. It's inevitable that you'll end up in the rough at some point, and this kind of punishment (not to mention the thorny, physical punishment) takes some of the fun out of a round.
Other than the two water holes, there weren't a lot of memorable holes. Lots of good, solid holes, but nothing that really sticks out. There is very little elevation, open space, or anything else that makes the holes look or feel different.

Other Thoughts:

This is a solid course and will work your technical game. I thought the fun factor here was a bit less than most of the other Charlotte courses I played, but that is only because the bar is set so high in the area. This would be the best local course in many parts of the country. There are a lot of similarly rated courses on this side of town, so it's easy enough to pair with several other places for a good day of disc golf.
Was this review helpful? Yes No
2 5
tank.brooks
Experience: 13.9 years 15 played 2 reviews
3.00 star(s)

Excited to see another course 2+ years drive by

Reviewed: Played on:Jun 6, 2011 Played the course:once

Pros:

Nice fairways, Love the elevation changes,
its exciting to see some holes where water comes into play. easy to follow from hole to hole.

Cons:

Since this is a course that is still in the works. i will ignore things like benches, signs and tee pads, those will come in time,

Other Thoughts:

I always enjoy a new course, and this is a great one,
i do miss having some more open courses, where i can really let it rip, but courses like these force me to be accurate and consistant so thats a plus..

Go Give it a shot. its a great course.
Was this review helpful? Yes No
Top