However if Innova were to release this many new discs and plastic options in such a short time frame, I can't help but think that they would be lambasted.
There is really no way to say this without sounding snarky, which is not my intent, so DanJon I apologize in advance, and this is not directed solely at you, despite me quoting you. Anyway, sometimes I wonder if people check facts before they speak, or just blurt out whatever comes to mind?
Lets play a game called "Facts are Hard"*(if you don't want all the facts, just skip to the part in bold below)
In the year 2014, MVP had 6 new molds hit the market (Atom, Impulse, Motion, Tesla, Inertia and Switch) and 1 new plastic was released (Electron). If you want to count Axiom, then I get to count Millennium and Discmania when we do Innova later. If we count Axiom the total grows by 7 discs for 1 year total, including forming a new company, of 13 new molds and 1 new plastic.
Let's look at Prodigy. In 2014 Prodigy had 6 new molds released(H2,H4,H1,X1,PA3 and M5) same as MVP, and launched 2 new plastics (glow 400 and 750). In 2013 (launch year) Prodigy released 18 molds and 3 plastics (11 more molds and 3 more plastics than Axiom's launch).
Trilogy had a big year, with 13 new molds approved, and a new plastic (Frost and derivatives). DD lead the way with 5 discs releases(Felon, Freedom, Enforcer, Thief, and Witness) and Lat and Westside had 4 each.
The Innova trio (including Milleneum and Discmania) had only 8 molds released. Of these Innova released the Whale, Thunderbird, Daedalus, Foxbat and Nova. However they went batcrap crazy, releasing XT and Gstar plastics, to bring their currently produced plastic types to a shocking 17 different blends (DX, DX Glow, Pro, R-Pro, McPro, Yeti Pro, KC Pro, JK Pro, XT, Champ, Champ Glo, Jolly Launcher, Blizzard, Star, GStar, EchoStar, StarLite).
Discraft was the model of restraint, releasing only the Buzzz OS and Heat for new molds, although there were lots of special edition Buzzzes, and BigZ plastic to make shop owners grumpy...
Cutting to the chase: If you want to look at facts Innova released 5 molds and 2 new lines of plastic in 2014, and MVP released 6 molds and 1 new plastic (with only one disc in it so far, and no promise that existing discs will be run in Electron). Not a huge difference in molds.If you talk to the owner at your local store owner he/she will probably tell you that a new mold is no big deal to handle. Hopefully it drives traffic and helps sales. On the other hand, an entirely new plastic is a nightmare, because now you have to find shelf space for many molds in that new plastic (think of all the different Gstar releases we saw this year) and gauge demand for certain mold in the new plastic vs the old, which is something of a gamble.
I'm not saying Innova should be lambasted. As a player I love Gstar, and I'm glad options are out there. But I'm not sure how anyone sees MVP's growth as being out of line with the industry.
*mold approval info pulled from the .xls file located here:
http://www.pdga.com/documents/pdga-approved-discs