Hard to put my finger on it, it just didn't "click" for me. Maybe it's a hair too shallow? It just didn't feel like I was releasing it cleanly on putts (my putting motion is sort of a push/spin hybrid, probably 75% push). My search for the perfect putter is a whole other ball of wax; I'm still trying out some of the suggestions made in another thread about that. But I do like the Atom for throwing. The Anode just felt weird to me; I don't like discs with a smooth curve between the rim and the flight plate, I prefer a nice corner that my fingers can use as a reference point. It was okay for fan grip throws.
I am mostly a BH player but I do like to throw anny FH putter approaches; reminds me of my Ultimate days. Almost any other FH throw I have to make, I use one of my Vibram discs, my grip feels more secure.