West Lake in Davenport IA is a really nice course, but when it is tricked out in the longs the aggressive use of the lake and thick rough makes several holes virtually unplayable for someone of my skill level. It's brutal in every sense of the word and pretty much impossible for someone like me not to lose half a dozen discs in one round. While having a course like that seems good for the sport in an abstract sort of way, I'd hate it if it was the closest course to my house.
Now from the perspective of designing a disc golf course on public land for public use, I have a hard time justifying using 30+ acres of public land for a course as hard as West Lake. It seems to me that a course designed to be attractive to the top 10% of disc golfers is catering to a very small portion of a demographic that is pretty small to begin with.
We did a road trip to the quad cities (IL/IA border) this summer, and West Lake Park blew my mind. Way to tough for the average player. I went there knowing the reputation, but not expecting that monster. We saw a family playing with catch discs on hole 1. I tried to explain a few rules to them, but it is pointless there. Hole 2 is a 200+' forced carry over water, with no other route. They either quit after 1 or after losing their catch discs on 2.
The weirdest thing about that place is it is in a multi-hundred acre park with plenty of family camping. You would think a more tame course would make more sense in a place that is sure to get plenty of beginners.
So, West Lake is great for 1000 rated players, not so for the rest of us. I hope to go back in a few years, when hopefully my skills have improved.