The facility improvements are awesome, and they are doing a great job curbing the erosion and adding amenities. None of these items constitute a 5 disc rating though.
Hole 3- the bushes on the left side that blocked the straight shot at the basket should have never been removed. This was a great hit a hole then hyzer shot, now it opens up bad shots going to the basket.
Hole 4- tee and basket change, this WAS the most unique hole on the course and one of the more unique forced shots in Augusta. It was designed to mimic an old hole at PK that was removed due to the redesign. The one that you had to throw a spike hyzer over the tree. This was a good hole replaced by another boring straight 250 foot hole.
Hole 7- Has 2 excellent par 4 positions that are never used anymore and have been removed from the design. Where the basket is now is basically a landing zone for the shot down the hill similar to the old hole 18 at PK.
Hole 13- The island of trees in the middle of the fairway were cut out, this created a 2 route shot and was a decent design feature. Now the shot is open to someones big S curving shot.
Hole 15- Why would you cut out those trees/bushes on the right corner of the hole?!?!? This hole is short 200 foot and technical and about 50 feet of brush was taken out to benifit someones S curve shot. This change baffles me.
Hole 16- The new pin position is just ok, the old one forced someone to throw a turnover shot that held its turn for 300 feet this was one of the best holes at PK.
Hole 18- Move the basket 30 feet to the right? makes it much easier for the sidearm and the basket was placed in a spot where many people "miss".
Basically seems like many of the physical changes to the course were done with out thought for the masses and creates "easier" holes for certain locals. Many of the long time players in the area are not a fan of those changes.
The "facility" changes are excellent and are great for the course and the park, but when changing holes at least leave the old sleeve in the ground to move it back and forth.
I finally got back to PK this Sunday,with a newborn at home I haven't gotten to play as much as I used to. I absolutely agree with your first and last statements, as well as the comments about hole #4.
However, I think most of the other layout changes are very minor;
Hole #3 The smart play for 2 is still the RHBH hyzer shot, anything else is spray and pray.
Hole #7 Alternate basket location haven't been used here in quite some time before the recent changes. I think it's unfair to lump this in.
Hole #13 A drive here still has to finish right for a chance to deuce. A big S shot puts you in the trees.
Hole #15 Just the opposite of 13, A drive here still has to finish left for a chance at two. A big S puts you in the trees.
Hole #16 that same long turnover shot still serves you well, just leaves you a little short of the new pin.
Hole #18 This was already the easiest hole on the course for many players, now it's just more friendly to flicks and lefties than RHBH.
I don't think the changes deserve the inflated reviews the recent ratings have included, but the course is in better condition than it has been in years. I rate the net effect of the changes as a positive.
This was and is the most beginner friendly course in the area. If you want more challenge, there are several nearby options.