Wrong or not, my perception from their marketing, is that Prodigy is a boutique, elitist, disc maker, for top pros. Whereas someone like MVP is a boutique disc maker for beginner to mid-level DGers that have the money to buy good quality discs (at least in a durability sense). I fit the later, but not the former. Then after throwing Prodigy discs, the plastic didn't appeal to me, and they were a bit more overstable than I expected, so I lost interest in giving them a chance. Plus, with so many options for Discs, unless you find a real gem (like my MVP Volt) you end up wanting to go with the long timers with trusted discs, at least I do.
The only reason I tried Prodigy was because I felt bad for how Innova was treating Will, or just the plight of poor Pro DGers in general, and the story I heard about why Will joined Prodigy made me want to give them a chance.
But at this point, the sympathy has worn off. If I'm gonna give a newer manufacturer a chance, I'd rather go with Legacy, who seems to be more down to Earth, and has a lot of really good Pro DGers from California joining them. Plus my Icon Patriot flies great from the first use, and is getting better as it wears in, so I have a Disc from them I already know I like.