SuperWookie
Birdie Member
- Joined
- Apr 9, 2019
- Messages
- 429
For what SW is talking about, I'm just realizing this stuff too and experimenting with it.
But for starters, think of a baseball bat swing. Say you hit a belt high pitch. You don't swing the bat belt high the whole time even though that's a natural height...the bat comes down from the shoulders, hits the ball belt high, and finishes arcing up and around the shoulders.
Same thing in the disc golf throw. If you look at your sequence of images, SW's right/throwing elbow follows that purple line quite well along the forward swing. Then look at where it is in the follow through, it's arced up and around his body...not just continuing on the same "flat" plane the whole time. You can also see the shoulder tilt and how they are angled relative to the arm throughout the shot.
The red line is meant to show the path of the elbow from release to this point in follow through....sorry it's a little sloppy from this perspective. Maybe the arc should have been a little more U shaped rather than the upside down arc. Point is that the arc goes upward to here.
![]()
So if you go frame by frame through the SW screen shots, it goes like this as far as the arm/disc path from beginning to end: flat on the initial turn back, then the disc arm is tilted from left, down to the right, then his elbow actually goes down below parallel with the disc above it on the pull, then back to flat right before the hit, then still flat at the hit, then his arm path has a subtle tilt up from left to right on the follow thru. So it's actually changing a lot throughout the swing. It's not like it's some perfect tilted path like a bat would take in baseball or golf, like this image shows, it actually changes many times throughout the throw.
![giphy.gif](https://proxy.imagearchive.com/180/180517d3746fff59ade1284a11599620.gif)
And hitting a ball with a bat or club is not the same as the disc golf swing. The disc is connected to your arm and hand. The bat/club is the only thing connected to you in a baseball swing. The ball is in space and you can come into it from any number of planes and angles to hit it. Whereas when you throw a disc, your arm and hand have to be on the path/plane you want the disc to come out? Right? So I'm not following how that is the same or correlates. Not saying you're wrong, I'm probably just not understanding something or a lot. But to my eye, and knowing all the stuff I know about a baseball, golf, tennis swing, I'm not seeing how they are the same here.
I'm really confused by a lot of this. I understand the baseball swing and the golf swing perfectly and very well. But I'm finding the disc golf swing not like it in some very key areas. Or at least I'm not understanding how they are so similar in those areas. The ball in golf and baseball is separate from my swing or bat/club. But the disc is connected to me in disc golf. So that is where I am really struggling to understand a lot of these concepts you guys are talking about. Sorry. Hopefully more explanation will help unlock this for me. I'm really really determined to understand this and then do it, but right now, I'm just drowning in some of these ideas, and then how to even accomplish them as they seem impossible.
Thanks