I have over 20 Outlaws in many colors and plastics, never had a "flippy" or "huge dome" one, but im sure there are some freaks out there, I've seen weird stuff like that in some of their molds, but its not that common. The most understable i have is a 166g FR Yellow and it started out with just a little turn and beat in very quickly, i stick to 172g+ with Outlaws and never had an issue after that.
I would take it back to where you bought it and tell them somethings wrong with it, or go to the Legacy facebook page and post a picture with description of what its flying like, the Legacy guys would replace that in a heart beat, they are awesome.
I Remember when i bought a big stack of MVP Shocks at release expecting them to be super beefy and they were understable out of the box, i was pissed too, but i contacted MVP and they replaced every single one for no cost.. most companies have inconsistencies and will gladly replace them for free if you are unhappy.
By the way my production run blues are awesome, so if you like blue try one of the new ones instead, you wont be disappointed.