I don't know about you, but yeah. That would be for me. Pleasant demeanor, and smiles a good bit matters to me. Male or female. Call me silly that way. BTW, each is a determined player too, but that matters less to me. Same goes for men on my cards.
It's why Barsby is one of my favorite Pro players. Simon is up there too. Nate is my favorite. He jokes, laughs and is serious at times. But i define his demeanor by his pleasant nature.
Agree 100%, but I get Matt's point and I think you have expressed agreement Lyle. There is certainly a double standard with what "attitudes" we expect from women and men so I agree on a macro cultural level with the premise and am certainly guilty of having to check my own bias at times. But if I'm wanting to have a good time in a casual round I prefer both my men and women card mates to be smiley and pleasant people, or I wont be playing more rounds with them. If your out there being all serious and game facey during a casual (even semi competitive casual) you wont be back in my group, but to each their own. I also don't surround myself with people who take life too seriously generally speaking.
In a competition I "prefer" the same, but I don't control who I play with, so I'm not going to let a stone facer get me down and certainly wont make assumptions on who they are off the course because I know too many athletes where this is night and day. Some people just get in the zone and stay there and maybe that's all this Cat thing is. I have had rounds with this type before and the minute we hit tourney central and grab a post round beer the guy turns into Gandhi. You just never know.
I prefer silly, but serious in competition. I have good friends I play casual rounds with that are full of jokes, razzing, the whole bit, but when we get carded up during a tourney everything is toned down. Of course it is. It's the nature of competition. I actually have to make more of an effort to really tone it down because I've gotten the impression at times from some of the guys that I'm not taking the competitive round as serious as they would like and I don't want to be "that guy".
As a fan, like Lyle, I tend to root for the more pleasant guys. It seems to me that guys like MJ, Barsby, Simon, Nate, Dollar, etc are likely really cool guys off the course. Nate doing commentary has confirmed that, so I'm a huge fan. However, the same may be true for someone like Cat, Ricky or other guys/girls that appear very serious on the course, but I don't know them personally, so I'll root for those that carry a more casual attitude into competition. I've always done that in every sport. I hate Cam Newton's winey demeanor on the field. I have never rooted for him, but his teammates, journalists, and the people who know him well often jump to his defense and say he is a wonderful guy in the locker room and off the field. The bottom line is these folks are trying to win something and different attitudes work for different folk.